Sunday, September 29, 2013
Response to Course Material Sep 29th
Reading The American Dream by Edward Albee really made me look at humans in a different light. Right after listening to the play read out loud, I turned to my friend and said "I don't get it." There's no point to this story. But boy was I wrong.
Our discussions started out small, mostly asking, "Wait, was the baby actually killed?" or "Why couldn't the characters find rooms in their own apartment?" But the small answers led to big revelations. Small ideas like the bumble having it's hands and tongue cut off grew into new ideas. The pain felt by The American Dream were in all the same spots the bumble was feeling pain. We connected the bumble as being The American Dreams's long lost twin. But seeing how much Mommy loves The American Dream and how dense and hallow The American Dream is, we saw what Mommy truly wanted. She wanted a bumble that was hollow, devoid of feelings and emotions, thus concluding that Mommy was chasing the American Dream all along. The american dream that is too materialistic. Honestly, I'm not sure how long it would have taken me to arrive at this conclusion were it not for the class discussions. But some things that did help were the class handouts about absurdest plays and types of comedy. From reading those two handout, I was able to label the play and recognize certain elements of low comedy and farce attached to the story. Our discussion on DIDLS (Diction, Imagery, Details, Language, and Syntax) allowed us to pick apart the play, piece by piece to find the hidden meanings. I always thought of the American Dream was to have a nice house in the suburbs, with a loving husband, two kids, a white picket fence surrounding your daisies and a Ford Model-T. I didn't realize that there were different takes on the American Dream compared to the description given to all of us in our history books. I realized through our discussion that authors don't put details in a book just because it was random, they were all there to tell a bigger story for the readers.
I ended up google-ing Edward Albee and found that he had incorporated his life into his play. He was raised in an orphanage until he was adopted into a rich family. He constantly disobeyed his mother. She had wanted him to be 'respectable' to society while he wanted to hang out with artists and homosexuals. Just thinking about it now, Albee probably felt like the bumble. He couldn't do as he wanted in his childhood. His parents were constantly trying to change him to fit into an acceptable society. He as later thrown out of his house and disregarded by his parents, much like the bumble. His realization of conforming to society, materialism/consumerism comes from his life living with his rich adoptive parents.
Albee emphasized, but condemns this idea of satisfaction and consumerism. The little story with the beige and wheat hat reminded me of the lifestyles that people are living in today. Kids get an Iphone 4S on Christmas and then they heard about the Iphone 5S in school the next week. Then what do the kids start thinking? "But I wanted the IPHONE 5S!" And of course, you get the grandmother in the background saying, "back in my day, we didn't have phones to complain about." The American Dream made me realize that he was mocking this so called American Dream. For our generation, the American Dream is probably to own a fortune 500 company at the age of 25, later get a good looking spouse, own a dog/cat and 2 children, drive a Porsche to pick up your children from school and own multiple million-dollar houses. But as Albee had emphasized, what happened to playing football in the backyard with your two boys and baking cookies with your grandma? The American Dream has evolved to the point that feeling are no longer a part of this American Dream. It has only the name to show, but not the filling to hold it up.
Both my parents came to America 20 years ago to live a better life, so they are like Grandma. They are the pioneers who headed out west to a new and unfamiliar life. They had to work hard for every penny. One time, I asked for a smartphone , but was rejected. At that time I didn't understand. Everyone else had a phone back in middle school and I still had a flip phone in high school. But guilt started forming as we discussed Albee's reason to writing The American Dream. I am that new generation, chasing that new American Dream (mentioned above ^). To be honest, I do care more than I should about what society thinks of me. I was banned from wearing makeup because my friends shouldn't care how pretty I am. They need to look beyond that and into what I'm truly made of, like Grandma's day old cake. I felt that Grandma really did come out of the play and talked to me personally, wanting me to understand that this play isn't 'pointless'. I can now understand why my parents believe what they believe. I really hope The American Dream touched others' lives just as it did mine.
Sunday, September 22, 2013
Open Prompt (Part I) September 22
AP English Literature and Composition 2006 Question 3
Country Setting as a Source of Values
Essay #1:
Score: 8
Score: 8
Right off the bat, the student starts off answering the prompt
in the first few sentences, even going on to mentioning how most writers
portray the values of a countryside and challenges that common view. He/she
uses Jane Austen's Persuasion to
specifically address and argue his/her point in the essay. And just from the introduction paragraph, we
know the student sees the country side's "nurturing, virtuous, and
peaceful quality". Although there are some punctuation errors (such as
using & instead of 'and') ; and run-on sentences, they only have a minor
effect on the quality of the argument. All three body paragraphs supported and
went back to the prompt by talking about each different value backed with
evidence. The use of transitions between paragraphs also help keep her essay
flowing between ideas. The organization makes it easy for readers to pinpoint
the certain arguments are. The author also ended with a strong conclusion by reiterating the argument. However, she does
not bring together all the ideas in the end by restating her three points to
make her conclusion stronger.
Essay #2:
Score: 6
Score: 6
The student does not start off by answering the prompt, but
waits until the end of the introduction to tell readers that the two settings
are the countryside and the city. He/she does pick examples from a specific
source, the Importance of Being Ernest. However,
the examples in the introduction aren't answering the prompt clearly about how
the countryside develops values. He/she explains why the use of the two
settings, the countryside and the city, make the story a comedy. The three
paragraphs don't support the prompt. The only thing being explained is the
confusion in the story with the two settings to create a comedy. The student
gives details, necessary and sometimes unrelated, and almost summarizes the
story for readers instead of picking out the details to help support his/her
point. Even in the student's conclusion, the only element argued was the
comedic confusion and the prompt about values in the countryside were never
explained. The essay would have been a much better fit for a different prompt.
Essay #3:
Score: 4
Score: 4
The student's introduction, however short, does answer the
prompt vaguely. His/her use of literary vocabulary does not always prove his
understanding of them (ex: syllogism). He/she never once brings up the words
'countryside' nor does he talk about values later on in the essay. The student argues
that characters were excused from their own stupidity because the author uses
the setting (the South) as a scapegoat instead of admitting the characters have
the flaw of ignorance. The student
automatically assumes the readers understood the South to be the countryside.
There is a lack of developed ideas to support ideas within the essay, and a
lack of details and explanation. The organization of the essay is somewhat
messy and according to his/her explanation of the piece, the student should
have chosen a different literary work to argue the prompt. The student seems to
use 'big' words to make his piece sound elevated, when in fact, it does the
opposite when he uses pompous words followed by extremely simple sentences. And
in the end, the conclusion does summarize some of his/her points but does not
answer the prompt.
Sunday, September 15, 2013
Closed Reading Sunday, September 15
Losing my father's smile: The devastation of Bell's palsy
It isn't often that you feel tears running down your face
after hearing about a case of Bell's palsy all the way in New York. It's sad,
but why aren't you crying right now? It really depends on how the author
conveys the story. Too often we've heard the mono-toned news reporters on Fox
telling us the latest headlines, and that's how we end up reading our news too.
But Harrison Golden is different. His choice of diction, details, and syntax
really create a story for us to live in.
Harrison was only 9 when his father developed Bell's
palsy. Harrison's father couldn't smile like he used to; it paralyzed half his
face soon after that. "Dad
paused our catch to sip from a nearby water fountain. When the mother and child
neared, he politely leaned into the stroller, waved and gave the baby his best
smile. But because the Bell's palsy still lingered, his grin looked more like a
smirk. The mother found his smile condescending. She ogled at him for a second
or two, then rushed her stroller away." Harrison explains the severity of
the issue using great diction. We didn't see a grumpy man stick his head into a
baby's stroller to give his best evil smile. Harrison uses 'politely' to
quickly establish what kind of man his father was. Harrison's father even
'waved' and gave the baby his 'best smile'. It wasn't any smile. His father was
sincerely trying. But instead of a half smile, we hear Harrison use the word
'smirk'. That's exactly how the mother saw the smile as she 'ogled' at him, not
'looked' at him, but 'ogled' at him as if he had something wrong with him. Just
from a few sentences, we know the sad truth of a kind man
is misinterpreted as 'condescending' because of a
disability.
Diction isn't the only thing telling
us a great story. Harrison incorporates detailed accounts of his own
life. "Breaking the promise I made myself was tempting, but I couldn't let
Dad not smile alone. I didn't care how hard I needed to bite my lip. I had
my critics. Kids would call me "Frowny the Dwarf." (It didn't help
that I was merely 3-foot-10 at age nine.) " Details such as biting his lip
and being called 'Frowny the Dwarf' really add sympathy to a story. Not only
did his father's life change, Harrison's life was turned around too. Any news
reporter could have just said that "Harrison refused to smile until he saw
his father's smile." That would have been seen as stubborn. But Harrison
describes his own suffering physically, which reflected his hurt for his father
emotionally. Being only 3-foot-10 creates an image of a small little boy who is
helpless to defend himself.
Harrison's use of syntax gives his
story a certain tone and quality. He often uses short, fragmented sentences
like "Then he called Dad."
to convey
emphasis or a distressed idea. There were few longer, poetic sentences because
this story wasn't meant to be seen as a piece of writing disconnected from his
childhood. The sentence structures are simple, and easily understood in a
narrative format, almost as if he was speaking as a fourth grader, creating an
innocence that reporters would not be able to convey.
Harrison, such a small boy, shared with
the world his suffering and sadness towards his father. However, I forgot to mention this; Harrison is now a
senior in college and his father was diagnosed back in 2001. Harrison does such
a great job with the usage of diction, details and syntax to suck the readers
into the past; into his story. As readers, we forgot that Harrison is no longer
in fourth grade, and we feel his pain, innocence, and longing to see his father's
smile again. Harrison's great combination rewound the clock to show America a
side to his family that no reporter would have been able to do.
Monday, September 2, 2013
Practice Questions (Chapter 3)
Ok, where to start. Let's starts with my weaknesses. Old texts with complex words that aren't used in daily English always trips me up, along with the wording. However, that isn't my biggest concern. After a few times of reading through any complicated wording, I start to understand the written meaning. The symbolism kills me though. In the Sample Questions, I had a hard time deciphering what each character and action may have meant. It happened again in Practice 1, except this time I also had issues with normal everyday vocabulary. Half the time I was wondering what a 'Nautilus' was and what kind of shell was THE shell in the poem. Luckily there is something called 'Google' and I have learned from that. Back to the old text problem. In Practice 3, I was quite limited in knowledge on the Bible and any Roman mythology (I prefer Greek). The poems I find easy are the ones that are relatively similar to contemporary writing. Practice 4 I got every question right....except #10. Basically any question that comes up about the type of poetry or type of rhyme, I miss. Looks like I should invest some time in the vocabulary department.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)