Wow time flies. It seems that it was only last week when we did our last 'Response to Course Material' blog. But in that short time, we covered Death of Salesman, analyzed some poetry, ate some crust-less pie, and tried to define tragedy.
In order to help us understand Death of a Salesman better, Ms. Holmes has us watch the movie first. And I must say, without the movie, I would have had a big issue following along with the text. The movie allowed me to see the visual effects the directors added into the movie to differentiate the past and the present. I did notice however, that while I was reading/watching Death of a Salesman, I made a few connections to The American Dream. Both of the plays talk about an American Dream, and both have 2 different dreams. Grandma symbolizes the old American Dream and Biff is the character chasing that old American Dream. He wants to work on the farms, and be free, not tied down in a suit and piles of papers. And Mommy and Daddy are constantly chasing the new American Dream, which coincidentally, Willy Loman was also chasing the new American Dream. I'm not sure if Holmes did this on purpose or not, but I could see little connection between the plays. (Ex: Mommy's short story about her wheat hat, and her need to conform to society/chairman of her woman's club vs Willy Loman's need to be well liked and accepted by society/fellow salesmen.) To be honest, I wouldn't have been able to connect these ideas together without the help of this class and the class discussions. I realized that Holmes gave us a much, much shorter discussion time for Death of a Salesman than The American Dream, probably because of the similar (but different) ideas in both. Or maybe the longer discussion on The American Dream was to help set up our brains and train them to think beyond just the words. But whatever you did Ms. Holmes, I now have a better understand of analyzing literature, so thanks you!
Along with those pieces, we also practiced some multiple choice and were given 3 handouts, Tragedy of a Common Man, Confusion and Tragedy, and Changing Definitions of Tragedy. This really gave me a different perspective of literature labeled as tragedies. Foster's paper argues why DOS would not be considered a tragedy and uses some pretty harsh language to prove his point, or rather, TRY to prove his point. I often found myself saying to Foster, "Dude. Times have changed! Where on Earth (with the exception of England) will you find some famous royal people?". Miller's argument in Tragedy of a Common Man made much more sense to me. The common man can represent a hero on the inside. It's not the status of the man that makes him a hero, therefore, allowing a common man to fall tragically too. So from now on, even when I'm reading chic-lit or something of the like, I'll be arguing with myself on whether or not one of the characters have made even a chic-lit a tragedy.
While annotating Death of a Salesman and The American Dream, it reminded me of taking a test. First you must read the question very carefully, then hunt down the answer. But, there are so many answers, sometimes even more than one correct answer. We sometimes even debate answers with our teachers because of what we believe. And sometimes with certain teachers, you can find the answer to question #5 in question #46, (vise versa) just like a book. Books will give you confusing things to ponder, and sometimes there is more than one correct answer. Sometimes while reading, we realize we found an answer way in the beginning of the book without realizing it. And at the end of the test/annotating the book, it makes you realize how much you'be learned or need to work on. I guess this will help with both my annotating and test taking when it comes time for that dreaded AP exam.
So we actually spend more time going through the poem Promises like Pie Crust than Death of a Salesman. Promises like Pie Crust is a poem written by Christina Rosetti. And once again, I must mention my failure to comprehend poetry at the level of an analysis. I didn't understand the connection with pie and promises. But after much discussion, I finally understood that pie crust crumbles (who knew?) just like promises. They are fragile and break, but it must be broken to get to the 'sweet stuff' on the inside (OK, I obviously don't eat pie, so thank you Max for bringing us your delicious crust-less pie). I always think the class discussion help me so much*. It gives me another perspective on the poem. Other wise, I would have sat there for god knows how long not knowing that pie crust crumbles.
It's funny how after every analysis of a piece we do, I always find a way for it to connect and affect my life whether it's Promises Like Pie Crust, Death of a Salesman or The American Dream. Ever since reading The American Dream, I've been checking myself to make sure I haven't become a Mommy or a Daddy. I've actually started using DIDLS instead of just reading books for pleasure, so all these hidden meanings come out of the story that wasn't there before. Now even my air-headed chic-lit characters turn into something a little darker. Um, thanks AP lit?
* (Some people will argue that I never talk through the discussions. And that's right, because taking the time to think of something to say is time away from the discussion to hear what others have to say. And trust me when I say this, but I think INCREDIBLY slow. So by the time I would have got something in my head ready to say, I would have missed 3 or 4 comments said. So that's enough of my lame personal excuse.)
Sunday, October 27, 2013
Sunday, October 20, 2013
Open Prompt (Part 1) October 20
AP English Literature and Composition 2009 Question 3
A Symbol
Essay #1: (I never thought handwriting would affect how a reader reads an essay, but I just learned what it's like to be a teacher, and boy is it hard work! Messy handwriting itself cannot and should not have an effect on the graders, but in this case (at least to me), I had a few issues with reading specific words. Overall, the quality of the essay was stellar, but it was frustrating at times not being able to read an entire sentence without deciphering what a word might have been. Now on to the actual analysis.) The student starts off with a strong entrance, answering the question within the first paragraph. He uses The Wild Duck by Henrik Ibsen to successfully explain how the symbol, the duck, is a reflection of the changes of characters throughout the essay. The students has specific examples in all paragraphs, however, some of the examples were a little vague, and without having read the book, I was slightly confused. The overall argument was successful however. The conclusion was a little lacking when it came to wrapping all the ideas back together, but it doesn't disturb the message of the essay too much. This essay may have received a 7 or 8.Essay #2: I sighed in relief as I scrolled down and realized that this essay was written with big, neat handwriting. However, after reading the first sentence, I noted minor grammatical errors that disturbed the flow of sentences. I often found myself re-reading sections such as: "Tennessee Willimas play "A Streetcar Named Desire" uses a lamp shade to symbolize covering up the truth, and this example exposes Blanche DuBois obsession with youth and her need to make everything in life appear better than it is." The student starts out well, giving a solid example of a symbol, but as the paragraphs go on, the students doesn't connect the reasons with the prompt and looses her argument in the middle. Even as the reader, I was constantly forgetting the main argument in her essay. Her examples did seem a bit lacking. She could have described them a bit more, but it was sufficient enough to get a main point across. Again, she does not reiterate her point about the lamps being the symbol for masking flaws. However, she does come back in the conclusion to tie the main idea together again. This essay may have received a 5-6.
Essay 3: This student starts off forgetting to underline her title of her novel and did not mention an author either. She also uses 'in my opinion' which is never something to put in an introduction. She was supposed to talk about the many aspects that the 'machette' symbolizes and how it affects the characters, but even in her introduction she only says "It symbolizes a higher level in power and the man who carried it was an intimidating man." That was her thesis. She then goes on to mentioning how the 'machette' was being used but none of the examples are solid ideas. Occasionally she goes off and gives extra details that do not pertain to the prompt. Her examples seem to be more of a 'matter of fact' kind of talk instead of showing the readers what she believes and why they support her argument. At the end, the students seems to have 2 conclusions. The first conclusion consists of multiple rhetorical questions aimed at the reader to dare the reader to refute her argument. And by that point, the student doesn't even mention the word 'symbol' and does no connect the 1st convolution to the prompt. It seems at the end, she is trying to prove why the 'machette' gave Okonkwo power instead of why the 'machette' symbolized power. The second conclusion reiterates what was said in the 1st conclusion but makes far less sense. She goes to including 'w/' in her essay surprisingly. And even at the end, the student can be seen contradicting her self. The last sentence to her conclusion should have been at least tying all the part(s) together, however she did not and ends with "So it symbolizes pride. Most of all." This essay may have received a 2, or 3.
Tuesday, October 15, 2013
The American Dream Analysis and Summary
The American Dream
Author: Edward Albee
(He was orphaned at childhood, adopted by a rich family and a homosexual. His mother kept trying to get him to become presentable to society)
Type: Theater of the Absurd (maybe), Comedy, Drama
Setting: The living room of Daddy and Mommy's apartment.
Characters:
-Mommy:
Author: Edward Albee
(He was orphaned at childhood, adopted by a rich family and a homosexual. His mother kept trying to get him to become presentable to society)
Type: Theater of the Absurd (maybe), Comedy, Drama
Setting: The living room of Daddy and Mommy's apartment.
Characters:
-Mommy:
- Can be seen as the antagonist of the play.
- Babies Daddy and Grandma, telling them what to do and having them repeat what she just said like a child.
- Materialistic, constantly searching for 'satisfaction'
- Epitome of a bad mother.
- Needs power over people
- Gender role swap with Daddy
-Daddy :
- Constantly needs reassurance from Mommy about his masculinity
- Has been reduced to a child-like state, repeating what Mommy says and talked to like a child
- Has changed genders through surgery.
- Like Mommy he is also chasing the new American Dream and wants 'satisfaction'.
- Gender role swap with Mommy
-Grandma:
- Grandma is able to travel from inside to play to the audience
- Symbolizes the 'Old American Dream' and it's values
- Only character 'acting' in the play
- Opens the door (physically) to the New American Dream
- Wisest character
-Young Man:
- Represents values of the New American Dream
- Is the twin of Mommy and Daddy's bumble
- Hallow shell. Pretty on the outside but no inside
- Becomes the new child for Mommy and Daddy
- Is able to interact with Grandma outside the play
- Is the 'satisfaction' for both Mommy and Daddy
Plot:
Mommy and Daddy start out sitting across from each other waiting for someone (and they don't know who or what they're waiting for). Mommy tells her short story of her trip to buy a hat, where we start to understand what the characters are like. Grandma comes in with a bunch of boxes, each nicely wrapped. We later find out that the boxes hold all the values of the Old American Dream. Grandma complains about being old and Mommy and Daddy complain about Grandma's bickering. Mrs. Barker ends up being the person they were waiting for and they can't figure out why she's there. There's a lot of sexual references thrown around between Daddy, Mommy and Mrs. Barker. After much confusion, Grandma finally reveals the history between Mommy, Daddy, Mrs. Barker and the bumble. And it is revealed that Mrs. Barker was supposed to come and 'replace' the bumble that just died. The Young Man knocks on the door looking for a job, and Grandma gives him the job of being the new bumble. However, no one seems to remember what the bumble looked like and comment on how Young Man/The American Dream looks familiar. So Mrs. Barker's case is solved, Mommy and Daddy are both happy, and Grandma leaves and joins the audience. Everyone's happy and 'satisfied' in the end.
Narrative:
There isn't quite a narrator in the drama, until the very end when Grandma decides to join the audience. Albee uses the character dialogue to move the drama along. However, you can hear Albee's opinions loud and clear through out the play. He mocks the new materialistic world and the shallowness of the new generation.
Style:
~Point of View- The play is set in third person with character dialogue to tell the story. However, at the very end, the point of view changes so that Grandma is telling the story.
~Tone- The tone of the piece is very dark from all the incest and violence physically to the imagery shown with the bumble. However, the tone is also mocking the current American society.
~Imagery- As I mentioned above, the imagery was especially during the part with the abuse of the bumble. His body parts were 'cut' off and from only that imagery you could tell what it may have symbolized. Ex: the cutting off of tongue means he doesn't speak, no guts, just that, and the cutting off of hands, he couldn't feel anymore. Albee uses imagery to show rather tell what characters are feeling.
~Symbolism- There was definitely a lot of symbolism put into the play. The symbolism of the abuse of the bumble is above and Grandma's boxes were brought up a lot. They symbolized the values of the old american dream packed and delivered out of the play. Grandma herself symbolizes the values of the old american dream because she isn't this materialistic, hallow person with no feelings. The Young Man represented the values of the new American Dream. His feelings from his twin have made him a hallow being, something perfect on the outside but feeling-less on the inside. This version of the American Dream only cares for materialistic values. The Young Man even says that the'll do anything for money.
Quotes:
Daddy: "Because it was empty." (Pg 66)- At this part, the characters have been talking about all the pretty boxes wrapped by Grandma and how Mommy used to bring it to school for her lunch but she would't open it. People thought it was empty. It can be interpreted as Grandma made the new American Dream. She made the hallow box/shell of a person. Grandma would fill it with chicken and her dinner from last night, but Mommy just gave it back (gave back those values) and ate the other children's chocolate cake and food (took new values, ones that meant close to nothing- they gave the food out of pity). Everyone viewed the box as empty, as in empty of values.
Grandma: "...My sacks are empty, the fluid in my eyeballs is all caked on the inside edges, my spine is made of sugar candy, I breathe ice; but you don't hear me complain...that's because old people are gnarled and sagged and twisted into the shape of a complaint." (Pg 82-83) - At the beginning of the quote, Grandma is talking about being old, ancient even. It represent the deterioration of the old american dream. The old american dream is physically dying. Also, in the second part, Grandma being physically twisted can be taken as mentally twisted, as in unstable. The new generation is viewing the old american dream as unstable, and dying. Again, the idea of crippling of bodies is expressed in the quote.
Theme:
Albee's American Dream warns that the current generation of Americans has gutted the heart and soul of traditional American values and replaces them with a materialistic longing to acquire complete satisfaction.
The American Dream is the title to this play, but seeing how absurd the play is, Albee is mocking the american dream by making it the label of absurdity. The tone is dark and often violence and deformity can be seen as symbolism in the play. It usually represents the lack of feelings the characters inhibit and it's harm to the old american dream (gutting the heart and soul). And from the plot, we definitely know just how materialistic each character is. The Young Man / The American Dream will do anything for money, even if it meant being the next child of the people who murdered your twin. Babies aren't made from love anymore, they are bought, and if their love can't be bought, then they are neglected. The old american values that Grandma had had been destroyed and given back to Grandma (quote #1) while the new generation goes for the newer, prettier elements. In the end of the play, the American Dream literally replaces Grandma when she walks out of the play and all characters forget about her and welcomes the new american dream.
Sunday, October 13, 2013
Closed Reading Sunday, October 13
'Fat letters' From Schools to Parents are Wrong
Schools used to be a social center for strictly learning, but now, according to Ruben Navarrette, the schools are unnecessarily controlling student diets and weights. Ruben is against policies of many states that take heights and weights to calculate BMIs and then sent to parents. Ruben's voice can be heard loud and clear with his use of diction, syntax, and language.
Diction is such an important part to hearing Ruben's voice shine in his article. For example, "hocus-pocus" isn't a word you often read while browsing through CNN, but Ruben uses it to describe dietitians' methods of labeling students by their BMIs. Ruben doesn't use words like "method", instead, he chose "hocus-pocus" to bring on a tone of immaturity, unprofessional-ism, and an overall tone of disapproval. Not only that, but "Schools have been slapping labels on students..." really gets the point across to readers that labeling students is harmful. Schools are not simple labeling students in Ruben's opinion, they're SLAPPING labels on students, making the action sound harmful and painful to students. Ruben made sure to carefully choose his words to create such disapproving tones throughout his article.
Not only is diction important, but Ruben's use of syntax helps readers feel his emotions. Throughout the article, short and or fragmented sentences can be found to emphasize ideas such as, "Fat letters.", "They had a point.", and "for mentally retarded." Just from a simple sentence, ("And what do students call these notes? "Fat letters.") readers can hear Ruben's emphasis on the name of the notes and it's importance. Ruben also uses a series of rhetorical questions to get readers to see the irony and hear his sarcasm. ("Schools can't afford foreign language courses, sports programs or music classes. But they found funds for dieticians?") Lastly, Ruben uses the -ing form of verbs constantly to show it's presence forcefully. He mentions that schools "are receiving letters regarding something that really isn't a school's business" which shows how prevalent it is in people's lives at the moment and it's urgency. Just through syntax alone, readers can note Ruben's disapproving and critical tone.
However, disapproving and critical aren't' the only tones heard throughout the article. I must compliment Ruben on his use of language. I'm not saying he chose to swear every other sentence; there wasn't a single swear word in the article. In fact, Ruben chose to use simple words and sentences casually to get his point across. While Ruben was being persuasive, his casual choice of words allowed readers to relate and understand him instead of just hear an argument. Furthermore, his use of the rhetoric as sarcasm allows the readers to sit back and laugh, making Ruben seem to be the better guy. He's not talking at you, digging around facts like a lawyer (no offense to anyone...), he's talking with you, and laughing with you too. He uses similar sentence structure for sentences, but changes up words for emphasis in his comparisons. "Many educators today might have a handle on math, science and reading. But they're flunking compassion, empathy, tact and sensitivity." Again, he almost sounds comedic, like you could add 'ba-dum tss" at the end. But we all know it's not funny, that Ruben is actually quite serious about the issue when he follows up these moments with a serious reality.
Ruben uses a mix of diction, syntax and language to successfully portray his disapproval but also sincere plead for understanding of the current 'fat letters' issue. His mixture of serious and comedic moments allow the readers to get a feel for his character and tone in the article making readers feel compelled to side with this author.
Diction is such an important part to hearing Ruben's voice shine in his article. For example, "hocus-pocus" isn't a word you often read while browsing through CNN, but Ruben uses it to describe dietitians' methods of labeling students by their BMIs. Ruben doesn't use words like "method", instead, he chose "hocus-pocus" to bring on a tone of immaturity, unprofessional-ism, and an overall tone of disapproval. Not only that, but "Schools have been slapping labels on students..." really gets the point across to readers that labeling students is harmful. Schools are not simple labeling students in Ruben's opinion, they're SLAPPING labels on students, making the action sound harmful and painful to students. Ruben made sure to carefully choose his words to create such disapproving tones throughout his article.
Not only is diction important, but Ruben's use of syntax helps readers feel his emotions. Throughout the article, short and or fragmented sentences can be found to emphasize ideas such as, "Fat letters.", "They had a point.", and "for mentally retarded." Just from a simple sentence, ("And what do students call these notes? "Fat letters.") readers can hear Ruben's emphasis on the name of the notes and it's importance. Ruben also uses a series of rhetorical questions to get readers to see the irony and hear his sarcasm. ("Schools can't afford foreign language courses, sports programs or music classes. But they found funds for dieticians?") Lastly, Ruben uses the -ing form of verbs constantly to show it's presence forcefully. He mentions that schools "are receiving letters regarding something that really isn't a school's business" which shows how prevalent it is in people's lives at the moment and it's urgency. Just through syntax alone, readers can note Ruben's disapproving and critical tone.
However, disapproving and critical aren't' the only tones heard throughout the article. I must compliment Ruben on his use of language. I'm not saying he chose to swear every other sentence; there wasn't a single swear word in the article. In fact, Ruben chose to use simple words and sentences casually to get his point across. While Ruben was being persuasive, his casual choice of words allowed readers to relate and understand him instead of just hear an argument. Furthermore, his use of the rhetoric as sarcasm allows the readers to sit back and laugh, making Ruben seem to be the better guy. He's not talking at you, digging around facts like a lawyer (no offense to anyone...), he's talking with you, and laughing with you too. He uses similar sentence structure for sentences, but changes up words for emphasis in his comparisons. "Many educators today might have a handle on math, science and reading. But they're flunking compassion, empathy, tact and sensitivity." Again, he almost sounds comedic, like you could add 'ba-dum tss" at the end. But we all know it's not funny, that Ruben is actually quite serious about the issue when he follows up these moments with a serious reality.
Ruben uses a mix of diction, syntax and language to successfully portray his disapproval but also sincere plead for understanding of the current 'fat letters' issue. His mixture of serious and comedic moments allow the readers to get a feel for his character and tone in the article making readers feel compelled to side with this author.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)