Sunday, December 22, 2013

Response to Course Material December 22nd

By now I probably should have learned not to put off my blogs until the last day to do them, especially when my electricity and Wi-Fi are at the risk of being obliterated by the tree next door, so this may just be the fastest, and shortest blog I write yet. We'll see. 

So, for the main topic? You guessed it, Hamlet. After finishing the play Hamlet, and watching 4 or 5 different versions of this play, I've come to realize how incredibly wrong I was when I was writing the Tiv tribe interpretation forum about the different ways to interpret Hamlet (or should I say the lack of ways one can interpret Hamlet?). Each version of the play had a little bit of a different interpretation of Shakespeare's same words. Earlier in the blog post, I had argued that there could only ever be 1 correct interpretation of Hamlet. Thinking back on it, I realized that they all seemed to tell a very similar message, have similar themes etc. I noticed that the Branaugh version of Hamlet made Hamlet a bit more aggressive than I thought he was in the original play whereas the Hawke version (the modern version) made Hamlet seem more 'in love' with Ophelia, but the themes messages where all still there. I've come to realize that all these interpretations are exactly what we see when we see our favorite teen books coming out in movies. Each person, movie producer, reader etc. has their own interpretation but they all come out with a similar story.  


Speaking of interpretation, the Ophelia poem for our forum post was also all about interpretations. The author seemed to portray Ophelia in almost an angelic light which some readers disagreed with when reading Hamlet. I had read Mary E's post for reviewing and she made a great point about Hamlet falling from grace (kind of like Lucifer) and becoming the devil, defying God's orders etc. I think that's a great point. It's kind of amazing how many books, even today, are still linked to religion. We all know the book City of Bones right? Believe it or not, I've found quite a few religious references, for example, did you know that Valentine represents Satan? He does create The Circle and Morgenstern actually means 'morning star'. I think you can figure the rest out from there. So where do I get all these crazy ideas from? Well, it's called reading How to Read Literature Like a Professor. When in doubt, it's from Shakespeare...or the Bible right? 

What did everyone think of the NPR story about Hamlet being performed in prison? It really surprised me how much I enjoyed listening to that. Before I listened to it, I thought 'oh jeez, prisoners performing Hamlet? Someone's going to die'.  Instead, I learned that prisoners are just normal people like you and me. We all take a step in the wrong direction sometimes, and that's exactly what happened to these prisoners. The only difference between the prisoners and I is that I've made fewer wrong decision. To see/hear prisoners comparing their lives with Hamlet was such an abstract idea, but now I understand why this was a step in the right direction for these actors. I think this story really made a big impact on my life, and how I will act in the future. I was raised to always stay away from the really sketchy looking people, but really, it's what's on the inside that counts. To be honest, the big guy calling everyone minnows reminded me of a child saying "I'm going to be king when I grow up and you will all have to be my servants!" The image these prisoners have really don't reflect what is going on inside them, and Hamlet was what brought them all together. An hour of this NPR recording has really altered my view on people, and I will definitely take this story into account as I move on in life.

Sorry I may have some really weird breaks in here due to my Wi-Fi and electricity problems. I'll make sure to edit this before anyone reviews this!

Sunday, December 15, 2013

Open Prompt (I) December 15th

AP English Literature and Composition 2008 Essay

Prompt: Function of a Foil

Essay #1: The student starts off with a very strong introduction, using Joy Luck Club by Amy Tan as the example to the prompt. She explains right away that Huang Tai Tai is the foil to Lindo Jong and explain that the characteristics of Huang Tai Tai accentuate the characteristics of Lindo Jong and emphasize their differences. This introduction shows that the student knows what a foil is and it's purpose, making it a great way to start off the essay. However, the body of the essay seems to contain too much summary and not enough information about Huang Tai Tai. All the information is aimed at Lindo Jong, explaining what kind of personality she has, and only giving up a little bit of information about Huang Tai Tai. The overall essay seems to contain the evidence needed to convince the reader somewhat that Huang is the foil to Lindo. The student ends the body paragraph with "She learned to respect herself and therefore illustrated the themes and meaning of the book." which is a little far from the original prompt: the function of a foil. Although the student does come back in the conclusion to wrap everything up, I don't agree with this student receiving a score of 8. The reader quotes that  “Huang was able to brainwash Lindo into thinking she had a good life . . . , and
that she owed everything she had to Huang.” was a good explanation to why Lindo was a foil to Huang, but that is only 1 example, the rest of the essay seemed to summarize the story to much.

Essay #2: This student's essay was not extremely clear in the beginning who Celia's foil is (from The Color Purple, no author given). The entire essay seems almost like a summary of the novel, focusing on Celia's struggles to becoming independent from the men in her life. To readers, it almost seemed that Shug was Celia's foil as the reader had also noted, but it turns out Celia's father is actually her foil when she states "Although Celia's father makes a brief appearance at the start of the novel, he attempts to affect Celia's life, setting as a foil, he represents every characteristic that Celia learns not to be." It isn't until this sentence is it clear to readers why Celia's father could serve as the foil. The essay does not effectively show that the student understood what a foil is and goes into too much detail such as Celia sinking karaoke at a bar and making special jeans to fit everyone's needs. The essay's message would have been better conveyed had the student just stuck to explaining why Celia was trying to be different from her father and not even included Shug, which confused readers. The student receives a score of 6, which is quite reasonable. The student's vocabulary is diverse and there aren't major grammatical errors. The main issue is introducing readers to another potential foil to Celia and not explaining who exactly the foil is at the beginning, which ends up confusing the readers later on.

Essay 3: This student starts off by stating that "Baba is a foil to Hassan", however, that sentence is followed by "He emphasizes good qualities in Hassan" which does little to prove to the readers that the student understood the meaning of a foil. The student does little to explain what characteristics of Baba that emphasize Hassan's good qualities. The student seemed to actually explain the similarities between Baba and Hassan, how they are both dishonest at times and how they are both loyal. The only contrast seen between the two characters is the description of Baba being 'extravagant' while Hassan was humble. The conclusion of the essay strays very far from the initial prompt and ends with explaining the 'meaning' of The Kite Runner (and does not include an author) as loyalty and friendship. The student's concluding sentence states that "Baba's foil to Hassan helps show this [loyalty and friendship] throughout the novel." which gives the impression to readers that the student did not quite understand what a foil is. The entire essay is a bit too 'simplistic' (as the reader had also noted) and contained incorrect grammar, overly simple sentence structures for an AP student (such as "Hassan is just like this.") and wandering ideas. The student never fully explains why Baba is a foil to Hassan. The explanations are thin and contain few details. The reader gave a score of 4 which accurately represents the student's lack of focus and knowledge on this topic. 

Sunday, December 8, 2013

Closed Reading Sunday, December 8th

Miley Cyrus Has a Problem


Movie stars are often criticized for the actions they take to becoming famous and getting the attention of the media. It wasn't surprising to find the article Miley Cyrus Has a Problem in CNN's opinion section. The article's author, Dean Obeidallah, boldly uses diction, syntax, and details to show his disapproval of Miley Cyrus's actions to gain attention. 

It is obvious that Obeidallah is not a fan of Miley, and this can be seen through his bold use of diction. The first thing readers process from Obeidallah is that Miley is an 'addict'. Obeidallah then goes to allude fame to being a 'drug', the drug that Miley is addicted to. This creates a much bigger impact on readers than just saying that she wants fame because the author has now connected Miley to a mental problem. Miley is also accused of "manipulating the media" giving readers the idea that Miley has is sly and can't be trusted. On top of that, Obeidallah believes that Miley will continue to do more 'outrageous antics' to keep the media interested. Antics is referred to as a prank (dictionary.com) which highlights Obeidallah's earlier argument that Miley can't be trusted or taken seriously. When the author combines that with 'outrageous', we get the image of the stereotypical immature teenager pulling yet another prank and wasting their youth away. A few words usually don't make a big difference, but when put together intelligently like Obeidallah does in his article, disapproval and criticism can be seen leaking out of the pages. 

Not only is diction an important factor Obeidallah applies to his article, but he also uses syntax to emphasize his feelings towards Miley Cyrus. The very first sentence readers see is, "Miley Cyrus is an addict." Obeidallah uses a short sentence to add emphasis, like it is an indisputable statement. Readers also see short asides inserted within the article, separated by dashes like "And on some level, I -- along with others in the media -- am enabling her addiction." By doing this, it seems that the author is reaching out to his audience to make a connection with the readers, making it similar to a personal conversation face to face. 

Lastly, Obeidallah uses details to enhance his portrayal of Miley Cyrus. Obeidallah compares Miley to Sarah Palin and Donald Trump because they both became 'fame junkies' and became "nothing more than a walking punch line." Not only that, but he compares Lady Gaga and Miley Cyrus. While both have a quirky sense of style, Obeidallah is constantly explaining that what Lady Gaga does benefits people and Miley only harms people. He mentions that Miley Cyrus smoked marijuana publicly in Amsterdam (because it was legal) where as Lady Gaga goes on television to talk about her marijuana addiction experience and why people shouldn't go down that same road. Along with comparing Miley to Lady Gaga, Obeidallah goes on to praising Lady Gaga for her involvement in making a more positive world like supporting the "don't ask, don't tell policy." This set up the possible positive image that Miley could have been, but she chose to give society a negative image and message. Obeidallah specifically uses these examples to show his disrespect and disapproval to Miley Cyrus. 

Obeidallah's disapproval of Miley Cryus is obvious when he uses certain words to connect Miley to negative ideas while changing sentence structures to connect with the readers to portray his message better. On top of that, Obeidallah compares Miley to many other public figures, both like and not like herself, to show the disapproving qualities she possesses. Just through diction, syntax and details, Obeidallah has provided great evidence to readers of his disapproval of Miley Cyrus. 

Sunday, November 24, 2013

Response to Course Material November 24th

Each Course Response I post makes me realize just how fast (or slow) this year has gone by. And unfortunately, Senioritis kicked in about a year ago, and it's still going so that doesn't seem to be helping my case very much.  At least this will be posted before midnight, maybe.

So let me tell you about my experience of being a fish. It's quite interesting and amusing actually. Thanks to AP Lit, I can now sympathize with my own guppies. Just kidding. Our fish bowl discussions were supposed to resemble a fish bowl. There's 4 fish in a fish bowl, each discussing among themselves, ignoring the heartless humans who always forget to feed them. By certain means such as self-will or Ms. Holmes, are they then removed from the tank to then face regretful reality; they didn't say all that you wanted to say. So while the fish in the fish bowl are awkwardly looking at each other, the fish outside are gasping for air, waving their fins around trying to get someone's attention to put them back into the bowl. On a less abstract note, the fish bowl discussions were pretty useful to me. I liked hearing what other people have to say about Death of a Salesmen  instead of the same 4 or 5 people always talking. It threw a few more ideas into the pit. The discussion about the wire recorder was especially helpful. Even though Ms. Holmes had to keep throwing food into the bowl to get the fish to bite the wire, in the end we all easily understood the significance of the wire recorder because instead of waiting for someone to blurt out the answer, we all thought for ourselves to get ourselves back into the bowl. At least that's what I did. Being able to discuss with a smaller group makes me feel more comfortable, especially if I know that my ideas won't be shot down by 15 other people. I think this might be the case with people who are reluctant to voice their opinions.

Last month, Ms. Holmes challenged me in the last course response blog to see if I can find the connections between Death of a Salesmen and Hamlet. One that was quite obvious was the suicide present in both books. Hamlet is noted to be suicidal while Ophelia actually kills herself and Willy also goes down the same road. So what makes both of these characters suicidal? Maybe the fact that the characters may be wavering between insanity and sanity? Hamlet may or may not be mentally stable while Ophelia eventually becomes crazy and Willy, although noted not to be crazy, is disillusion. On top of that, 'ghosts' are seen in both stories, which adds to the 'mental/delusional' state of both Willy and Hamlet. The 'ghosts' are what influence and cause the tragedy in both characters. Ben 'talks' to Willy and Willy gets the idea that becoming successful does not always require hard work. Hamlet on the other hand, is told by his father's ghost to kill the King  to avenge his death which in the end also gets Hamlet killed along with most of the characters creating another Shakespeare tragedy. It's amazing the similarities you can find between such different pieces and at such different time periods.

Before we had started reading Hamlet, we went through a few other practices like The Century Quilt. To me, getting a piece of literature and reading it with analysis within a short period of time makes me anxious. Where do you begin? How do I know this is actually a symbol and I'm not over thinking it? Wait, is this a reference to something that I don't know about? What does this word mean? (<--  that comes up more often than I'd like) And so on. After about 10 minutes of freaking out, I realized all I had to do was figure out the riddle (the meaning), and the answer was right there in front of me, all I needed to be able to do was decode the message just like the coded messages we used to pass around as kids in elementary schools. I was surprised to see that I actually got most of the symbols and hidden meanings. While I did miss a few parts, I was spot on on most of the other messages. Even though AP Lit is a college level course, it really just comes back to the basics of breaking things apart and simplifying them. My only issue now is organizing all my evidence and filling in the rest of the essay. But we still have time to work on that, right?

I'm not quite sure which is worse, the essays or the multiple choice. While the multiple choice gives you the answer, I have a hard time because of vocabulary. It's not just the vocabulary such as questions like "The following passage is an example of...a) metaphysical conceit b) Irony......" or the questions like "The poem can be best described as a(n)....a) ballad b) epic.....". I also have problems with the vocabulary just present in the passage/poem. Granted, the multiple choice has become easier after practicing a few times, but I noticed I do best on passages from a book I've read (for example the one we did over the summer with Pride and Prejudice and the one we did in the most recent multiple choice Jane Eyre). Having read them already, I could just skim the passage to see where it began and where it ended (I believe both started at the very beginning of the book) and go straight to the questions. It really saves a lot of time. So for anyone reading this blog, READ AS MANY PIECES OF LITERATURE AS YOU CAN GET YOUR HANDS ON BEFORE THE AP EXAM! From my own experience it made me relax to see something familiar, almost like I cheated fair and square. But also as a warning, some questions are asked pertaining to ONLY the passage given, and the AP test makers assume you are not drawing information from the rest of the book.

Lastly, we started to analyze scenes to obtain the mood and atmosphere. It's fun really getting to use your imagination. But being that it's an image, the class is usually split on what the picture may mean since there's always more than one interpretation. You've had that feeling right? When you're in an art museum (or am I the only one who likes those anymore?) and you come across a painting with splotches of color, you realize it is supposed to represent the artist's mood at that time. But after reading the description, all you see is the splotch of green in the corner as puke and the splotches of red as blood, something that resembled the bubonic plague, not at all the natural autumn scene the artist described.  That's kind of what happens in our lit class, but on a less dramatic scale. It's amusing to see from someone else's perspective what the picture looks like and going "Oooh so that's what your brain automatically processes..." (ex: the birthing cave). It allows you to see that the author of a story may be coming from a completely different perspective than you are interpreting the piece, so you need to think like the artist/author to get what they were trying to say. But it would be nice to go over what exactly we need to construct a concrete thesis. Or maybe explain what exactly is a verb phrase...I think there are more people out there than just me who don't quite understand the specific use of a verb phrase.

I promised myself that I'd write a shorter blog this time to save my peers some time and energy, but sorry, I don't think that happened this time. I'll definitely work on being more concise. It's really hard to top a blog that Ms. Holmes deemed 'a model' since you can only stay constant or go down hill from there. If I fail this class, at least I learned some life lessons (like realizing there's always more than one point of view and how to make life easier by simplifying your problems to better analyze the situation). Knowing me, this class might just save my life one day. I don't know, we'll see.

Saturday, November 16, 2013

Open Prompt (Part I) November 17th

AP Literature and Composition 2004 Prompt Question #3

Prompt: Roland Barthes: "Literature is the questions minus the answer."
(I could not find an actual prompt question unless that was it.)

N. Essay #1: N's essay is put together extraordinarily well. N starts off with a strong introduction, however a bit wordy, proposing the question, "Is this the best of all possible worlds?" which answers the prompt. However, one minor flaw in the absence of the author included with the title, Candide. The body paragraphs at first seem to include too much unnecessary information and summarized the story rather than answering the prompt, but N uses this to his/her advantage and most of his/her summary became evidence. However, there are still a few unnecessary parts. Despite that, N always goes back to the prompt, reminding readers why the information is important. The language used in the essay is pretty sophisticated and little to no grammatical errors occurs. There are a few instances where N gets too repetitive with a specific word or phrase.  The conclusion was solid, however, the use of The Prophet by Kahlil Gibrar seemed unnecessary and did nothing to the overall message in the essay.  The AP grader gave N an 8 which is a very reasonable score.

J. Essay #2: J starts with a strong introduction with an reasonable central question: "What does it mean to be free?". However, simply stating that the novel "explor[es] the limits that slavery and civilization place upon the novel's characters." is a bit vague. The beginning of the J's essay starts out strong and seems to be headed towards the right direction, but slowly J moves further and further from his/her central question. J concluded the essay stating that both the characters were not actually free, but never defined what 'free' meant. The definition could be implied through the context of the essay, however, J just didn't have that push to answer the question all the way. The conclusion strayed so far from the central question that it answered a different question. J ended up explaining why freedom is limited because of society instead of saying what it meant to be free. J was had inconsistent grammatical errors such as fragmented sentences and spelling errors, however they do not distract the readers too much. According to the AP reader, J used a good source and knew Huckleberry Finn well, however they kept "skirts around this [the central question] important issue." J received a 6. The main goal is to always answer the prompt, and without answering the prompt fully, a 6 is a reasonable score to give J.

U. Essay #3: U starts off with many grammatical errors such as "it's" instead of "its" and actually using "+" instead of "and". The tenses don't always match up either, and his can be seen throughout the entire essay and effects the flow of the essay a bit. According to the AP grader, Things Fall Apart is a great example to use, if used correctly, which U did not. (The title was not underlined also.) U states, "the main goal in the novel is to "prevent things from falling apart." and has a central question as "does anything ever stay the same?" which don't connect very well. U's body paragraphs were incredibly vague and did not include specific examples to support any of the question stated in the introduction. The essay is disorganized, with a total of 2 paragraphs; the first being the introduction and the second being one example and a conclusion clumped together. U obviously didn't have enough examples and did not think about the depth of the novel. instead of just the surface story. Even thought the 'conclusion' does answer his/her central question in the end by stating "things do change + never stay the same.", however there isn't enough evidence. U received a 3. The only thing that saved U from receiving a 1 or 2 might have been having a statement that answered a central question.

Wednesday, November 13, 2013

Death of a Salesman Summary and Analysis

Death of a Salesman

Author: Arthur Miller

  • Miller's family was pretty wealthy until they lost most of their money in the Wall Street crash. He was married to Marilyn Monroe at one point before divorcing her and marrying Inge Morath, his last wife. He was insistent on leaving his son with down syndrome out of the family. He died at the age of 89, right before he was about to marry his fourth wife. 
"Arthur Miller." 2013. The Biography Channel website. Nov 13 2013, 08:08http://www.biography.com/people/arthur-miller-9408335.

Type: Play

Genre: Tragedy

Theme: Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman suggests that valuing words instead of actions leads to a delusional perception of one's success; this delusion leads to a deterioration of relationships as well as one's own rational thinking.

Setting: Brooklyn and Boston

  • Loman house and backyard
  • Other places around Brooklyn and Boston
Characters:

-Willy Loman 
  • 60 year old 'salesman'
  • Always chasing the American Dream of wealth and success, and reputation
  • Cares about image too much, wants to be 'well-liked'
  • Suicidal and delusional
  • Father to Biff and Happy, husband to Linda.
  • Often found yelling at Biff and Linda, and not caring about Happy
  • Boasts too much, like Hapyy
-Biff Loman
  • 34 year old, unmarried son of Willy and Linda, brother to Happy
  • Used to be popular and a star football player in high school. 
  • Always getting fired from his jobs
  • Used to chase the new american dream, now always going back to the old american dream

- Linda Loman

  • Wife to Willy and mother to Happy and Biff
  • Very strong, holds the family together
  • Takes care of the money and runs the house(gender role swap)
  • Realistic (sometimes) and loyal
-Happy Loman
  • 32 year old, not married
  • Son to Linda and Willy, brother to Willy
  • Compulsive liar, always making himself seem better than he really is
  • Parents don't really care bout Happy, living in his brother's shadow
  • Constantly has affairs
-Ben 
  • Willy's older brother
  • Got right when he went to Africa to mine diamonds
  • Constantly shows up in Willy's illusions
  • He has the success that Willy is always going after
-The Woman
  • A woman from Willy's work place 
  • Willy's mistress
  • She causes the entire mess of killing Biff's dreams
-Charley
  • The Loman's neighbor
  • Successful businessman
  • Is constantly giving Willy money
  • Willy's only true friend
Plot: 
Act I:
The play opens with Willy coming home from a failed business trip, tired and exhausted. Biff and Happy had come back to visit their parents. Willy is constantly mumbling to himself, reminding Biff of his failure to live up to Willy's dreams. But Biff asks Happy if he wants to go get a ranch in the West to pursue an old american dream lifestyle. While Willy is downstairs, he has a flash back, which he does often, before all hope was lost for Biff to succeed in making Willy's dream come true. We learned that Willy and Biff were very close, and Biff was a huge star back in high school, and very close to getting the dream Willy was never able to get. During his flash back, he has yet another flashback with his mistress. Willy always gave The Woman stocking for payment. Snapping out of his flashback, he dismisses Happy and Charley comes over to see what all the noise was about. Charley offers Willy a job, but Willy refuses due to pride. Willy continues to regret not going with Ben where they found a diamond mine and got rich. Ben is usually present in most of the flashbacks. The boys and Linda come downstairs but Willy is outside again, mumbling and wandering around. Biff is constantly being scolded for looking down on their father, and calling Willy a fake (from seeing him with a mistress). We learn that Willy is trying to commit suicide with cars and inhaling gas but Linda refuses to take away the pipe to the gas, because that would take away Willy's  dignity, one of the few things he has left. Eventually, Biff and Happy decide they could go into sporting goods business together, which makes Willy extremely happy and to get money from Bill Oliver. 

Act II:
Willy is cheerful, and excited to see his boys succeed especially Bill. The boys invited Willy to dinner at a restaurant. Willy decides to go to Wagner, his boss, to ask if he could stop doing long distance commuting. Howard is found playing on his wire recorder and pays little attention to Willy. Willy eventually gets to talk, but instead argues with Howard because he didn't keep his father's promise of letting Willy get a job in the office. The wire recorder makes Willy extremely frustrated and it is at this point, when he is fired, that the salesman has died. After yet another flashback to the perfect american dream family they once had. Willy then heads over to Charley's company to ask for money, and meets Bernardo, Biff's childhood friend. Bernardo is extremely successful now, a lawyer in fact arguing a case a the supreme court. Charley's family is all Willy has ever wanted, to be well-liked and wealthy. Not to mention their extremely humble behavior. At the restaurant for dinner, Biff reveals that he did not even get to talk to Oliver for money and Willy's dreams are once again shattered. Willy goes and hides in a bathroom while on his flashback again while the boys go off with some girls. Willy goes back to the moment Biff's dreams were shattered, the moment he found Willy with the mistress and Biff had flunked math. Biff had figured out that Willy really isn't the great businessman he used to see him in, but a fake. Willy, coming out of the flashback goes to find a seed store. After the boys come back, Linda scolds them for not taking care of Willy (reverse roles again) while Willy is seen talking to Ben and trying to plant seeds in the unsustainable dirt. Biff and Willy get into another huge argument about Biff's failure but finally resolves it with Willy realizing that Biff still loves him. They all end up going to bed except Willy who continues his conversation with Ben about the $20,000 life insurance money he could give the family. Willy gets into his car and speeds away.

Requiem:
At Willy's funeral, it's obvious that he did not die a salesmen's death. He isn't surrounded with people from all over, it's only his immediate family and Charley. Biff declares that he now knows his real dream, and that is to world on the farms where as Happy says he'll live up to Willy's dream in the city. Linda paid off all the loans and now they were free, but Willy isn't there to enjoy the rest of life with her. 

Style: 

-Point of view: This was in the format of a play, so there really isn't a point of view.

-Tone: While this is a tragedy play, there is also a hint of humor in the dark story. The story is quite dark in that each character seems to have fatal flaws, and Willy especially, so you know from the beginning that his fatal flaw with result in the death of himself, hence the title. The mentioning of suicide makes the story even darker. However, small comical sections were added into the play such as the part when Happy is talking to a lady at the restaurant. He's showing off Biff and first asks the lady if she knew anything about football before throwing a huge lie, knowing she wouldn't know the difference. 

-Imagery: Some of the items that Miller uses such as the car and the wire recorder are objects that represent much more than they appear. Other parts of imagery come from stage directions and descriptions of the stage such as the gaps in the walls to represent Willy's daydreaming verses the present.

-Symbolism: 
  • Seeds: The seeds represent growth. Willy buys the seeds and tries planting them after being fired by Howard because he wants to try one last time to give the boys something at least, like food. But of course they won't grow the way he wants, kind of like how Biff didn't grow up the way Willy wanted because of Willy's own failure. 
  • Foreign land: Ben is said to have found diamonds, his wealth in a foreign land, outside of the city and through his own labor. That is also what Biff is trying to do by going out west and away from civilization. It is the old american dream, working hard and honestly to get what you want, unlike the cities that use others. The foreign land represents the treasures not found yet (ex: diamond mine) that need to be found by those who are willing to work hard. 
  • Wire Recorder: This symbolizes the reality that Willy realizes later on. A wire recorder can be played over and over again, just like Willy's memories, but you can't change them, just like Willy's memories. So going back to those specific moments won't change a thing. 

Quotes:
Act II Pg 90. Willy: "I've got to get some seeds. I've got to get some seeds, right away. Nothing's planted. I don't have a thing in the ground."

Willy is saying in this scene that he needs some seeds so he can go plant something in his 'garden'. He's trying hard to be able to give at least something to Biff to make him successful. He says "I don't have a thing in the ground," it refers to Willy not planting the seed to start Biff out in the right direction any good parent should. He's using this last chance to plant something, anything to help his family fulfill the dream when he's not there because he'll be dead. It's not until the end that Willy realizes in order to give anything of value to his family, he must do it from hard work. (He got the idea when he said he needs to plant something, but it's still not hard work if you do it half heartily the night of your death. )

Act II Pg 98 Willy: "I am not a dime a dozen! I am Willy Loman and you are Biff Loman!"

Willy is an idealist, and it is evident in the play that he really thinks he's a great man, a one and only, a special man, and so is Biff. He lived his whole life to make himself better than the guy next to him, to make himself the best, but Biff tells him the reality, that they are just normal people, incapable of doing much impact to anything really. This is the quote that explains basically all of Willy's values.

Theme: Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman suggests that valuing words instead of actions leads to a delusional perception of one's success; this delusion leads to a deterioration of relationships as well as one's own rational thinking.

All of Willy's goals, and past achievements are lies. He says he will fulfill his dream, and it's only talk. He says that his boys are working on a big deal. Again it's only talk, no work. He thinks that just because he says he did something, it means its true and it can be held accountable. He tells Charley that he needs a job after being fired but refuses the job that Charley offers, instead takes the money. His pride and delusions gets in the way of his goals often. His goal was to be like Ben. To him, Ben just traveled into a forest, and came out with diamonds. With that thought in your head, that you can be successful without the work, it makes Willy delusional, thinking that only your image a reputation counts to making you successful. The actual death of the salesman is at the moment of self realization with Howard's wire recorder. The wire recorder is like Willy. They can both keep going back to the past, rewinding what's in their memory, but it doesn't mean they can change anything. Willy realizes he can't change anything anymore. He finally realizes at least a little that he needs to take a little action, like planting the seeds. But it's such a shallow understanding that he doesn't realize how much hard work it takes to truly get something great. However, even at the end, Willy is still delusional when he though that doing suicide will allow his boys to achieve the dream he could not. Biff had failed Willy in obtaining the dream, and being Willy, he thought that was the only way to make the Loman name proud (because of course, he's deluded) and so they always argued. Even after Willy's death, Happy does not see reality and wants to try to fulfill Willy's dream. But Happy is also all talk and no work. He always says he's going to get married, he's going to get a family, he's going to fulfill Willy's dream etc. Chances are, none of those things will happen because Happy doesn't understand the value of working hard to achieve greatness.

Sunday, November 10, 2013

Closed Reading Sunday, November 10th

Rob Ford, Toronto’s crack-smoking mayor: Finally, a famous Canadian politician!



Today, it seems that nothing is ever a surprise anymore. Events such as the recent government shutdown didn't seem to phase many people at all. However, the news of Toronto's mayor, Rob Ford, admitting to smoking crack became a world wide hit within seconds. Diane Fransis is just one of the many authors covering this story. However, diction, syntax and details are some of the ways Fransis makes bias drips off each paragraph, giving the world a skewed view on Toronto's now infamous mayor. 

Diction is one of the many components Fransis uses to portray Ford's inadequate life outside of politics. The author constantly uses disapproving words like "refuses" and "impaired rant" to describe Ford's actions. Fransis uses bias by saying Ford "refuses" to resign when he only stated his indecision to resign at that moment; it shows the word's subjectivity. On top of that, Fransis goes on to accusing Ford of making an "impaired rant" which is also quite subjective. Sticking to the facts, Fransis could have used 'rant' to describe Ford's actions without the unnecessary modifier, 'impaired'. It is implied that Fransis was aiming at a much larger audience than just those who read the news everyday. She uses simple words and even a text lingo such as "FYI", and rarely does she include a word outside of everyday vocabulary. Her intentions were to make the article available to those less educated and for those with oxford vocabulary, it was made to be comical. With the addition of complex vocabulary, the article would have been much more serious. 

Not only is diction a part of the obvious bias in this article, syntax is also an important component. Most of the article includes long sentences and structures. The long sentences are generally more complex in structure, filled with commas and semicolons, it represents the author's enthusiasm in writing this story. She tries to make it flow, therefore making the story as a whole smooth and easy to read, also easy to laugh at. However, the short sentences such as "It's frustrating, but understandable.", are really emphasized. It's a short, complete idea and a statement. Included in that sentence is the use of a comma to emphasize 'understandable'. Had the sentence been switched around "It's understandable, but frustrating.", the frustration would have been the emphasis and main point.  

The last, but most important thing that Fransis uses to add bias in her article is the use of details. Often it's the background story that gets to people. She consistently adds little interjections throughout her article like "He blamed the press for not asking the correct questions." and includes the quote "Rob Ford looks like the kind of red-faced American trash who would knock down an old lady in the WalMart pharmacy line just to get this brother's Oxycontin prescription five minutes faster," (Ken Layne). Small details like these show Fransis's bias. These details could have been left out and the story would have still made a lot of sense, but the addition of these and choosing these specific examples to put into the article really show Fransis's disapproval of Ford. Not only that, but Fransis includes and explains Canada's usual lack of headline news anywhere in the world in order to emphasize the importance of this issue. 

Fransis's use of obviously subjective diction creates a disapproving tone while her syntax emphasizes on certain points and creates a comical tone. On top of that, Fransis adds details that are obvious to readers which side she stands on. Whether it's diction, syntax, or details in Fransis's article on the Toronto mayor, Rob Ford, Fransis uses these methods to create a bias report on the current situation in Canada. 

Sunday, October 27, 2013

Response to Course Material Oct 27th

Wow time flies. It seems that it was only last week when we did our last 'Response to Course Material' blog. But in that short time, we covered Death of Salesman, analyzed some poetry, ate some crust-less pie, and tried to define tragedy.

In order to help us understand Death of a Salesman better, Ms. Holmes has us watch the movie first. And I must say, without the movie, I would have had a big issue following along with the text. The movie allowed me to see the visual effects the directors added into the movie to differentiate the past and the present. I did notice however, that while I was reading/watching Death of a Salesman, I made a few connections to The American Dream. Both of the plays talk about an American Dream, and both have 2 different dreams. Grandma symbolizes the old American Dream and Biff is the character chasing that old American Dream. He wants to work on the farms, and be free, not tied down in a suit and piles of papers. And Mommy and Daddy are constantly chasing the new American Dream, which coincidentally, Willy Loman was also chasing the new American Dream. I'm not sure if Holmes did this on purpose or not, but I could see little connection between the plays. (Ex: Mommy's short story about her wheat hat, and her need to conform to society/chairman of her woman's club vs Willy Loman's need to be well liked and accepted by society/fellow salesmen.) To be honest, I wouldn't have been able to connect these ideas together without the help of this class and the class discussions. I realized that Holmes gave us a much, much shorter discussion time for Death of a Salesman than The American Dream, probably because of the similar (but different) ideas in both. Or maybe the longer discussion on The American Dream was to help set up our brains and train them to think beyond just the words. But whatever you did Ms. Holmes, I now have a better understand of analyzing literature, so thanks you!

Along with those pieces, we also practiced some multiple choice and were given 3 handouts, Tragedy of a Common Man, Confusion and Tragedy, and Changing Definitions of Tragedy. This really gave me a different perspective of literature labeled as tragedies. Foster's paper argues why DOS would not be considered a tragedy and uses some pretty harsh language to prove his point, or rather, TRY to prove his point. I often found myself saying to Foster, "Dude. Times have changed! Where on Earth (with the exception of England) will you find some famous royal people?". Miller's argument in Tragedy of a Common Man made much more sense to me. The common man can represent a hero on the inside. It's not the status of the man that makes him a hero, therefore, allowing a common man to fall tragically too. So from now on, even when I'm reading chic-lit or something of the like, I'll be arguing with myself on whether or not one of the characters have made even a chic-lit a tragedy.

While annotating Death of a Salesman and The American Dream, it reminded me of taking a test. First you must read the question very carefully, then hunt down the answer. But, there are so many answers, sometimes even more than one correct answer. We sometimes even debate answers with our teachers because of what we believe. And sometimes with certain teachers, you can find the answer to question #5 in question #46, (vise versa) just like a book. Books will give you confusing things to ponder, and sometimes there is more than one correct answer. Sometimes while reading, we realize we found an answer way in the beginning of the book without realizing it. And at the end of the test/annotating the book, it makes you realize how much you'be learned or need to work on. I guess this will help with both my annotating and test taking when it comes time for that dreaded AP exam.

So we actually spend more time going through the poem Promises like Pie Crust than Death of a Salesman. Promises like Pie Crust is a poem written by Christina Rosetti. And once again, I must mention my failure to comprehend poetry at the level of an analysis. I didn't understand the connection with pie and promises. But after much discussion, I finally understood that pie crust crumbles (who knew?) just like promises. They are fragile and break, but it must be broken to get to the 'sweet stuff' on the inside (OK, I obviously don't eat pie, so thank you Max for bringing us your delicious crust-less pie). I always think the class discussion help me so much*. It gives me another perspective on the poem. Other wise, I would have sat there for god knows how long not knowing that pie crust crumbles.

It's funny how after every analysis of a piece we do, I always find a way for it to connect and affect my life whether it's Promises Like Pie Crust, Death of a Salesman or The American Dream. Ever since reading The American Dream, I've been checking myself to make sure I haven't become a Mommy or a Daddy. I've actually started using DIDLS instead of just reading books for pleasure, so all these hidden meanings come out of the story that wasn't there before. Now even my air-headed chic-lit characters turn into something a little darker. Um, thanks AP lit?

* (Some people will argue that I never talk through the discussions. And that's right, because taking the time to think of something to say is time away from the discussion to hear what others have to say. And trust me when I say this, but I think INCREDIBLY slow. So by the time I would have got something in my head ready to say, I would have missed 3 or 4 comments said. So that's enough of my lame personal excuse.)

Sunday, October 20, 2013

Open Prompt (Part 1) October 20

AP English Literature and Composition 2009 Question 3

A Symbol

Essay #1: (I never thought handwriting would affect how a reader reads an essay, but I just learned what it's like to be a teacher, and boy is it hard work! Messy handwriting itself cannot and should not have an effect on the graders, but in this case (at least to me), I had a few issues with reading specific words. Overall, the quality of the essay was stellar, but it was frustrating at times not being able to read an entire sentence without deciphering what a word might have been. Now on to the actual analysis.) The student starts off with a strong entrance, answering the question within the first paragraph. He uses The Wild Duck by Henrik Ibsen to successfully explain how the symbol, the duck, is a reflection of the changes of characters throughout the essay. The students has specific examples in all paragraphs, however, some of the examples were a little vague, and without having read the book, I was slightly confused. The overall argument was successful however. The conclusion was a little lacking when it came to wrapping all the ideas back together, but it doesn't disturb the message of the essay too much. This essay may have received a 7 or 8.

Essay #2: I sighed in relief as I scrolled down and realized that this essay was written with big, neat handwriting. However, after reading the first sentence, I noted minor grammatical errors that disturbed the flow of sentences. I often found myself re-reading sections such as: "Tennessee Willimas play "A Streetcar Named Desire" uses a lamp shade to symbolize covering up the truth, and this example exposes Blanche  DuBois obsession with youth and her need to make everything in life appear better than it is." The student starts out well, giving a solid example of a symbol, but as the paragraphs go on, the students doesn't connect the reasons with the prompt and looses her argument in the middle. Even as the reader, I was constantly forgetting the main argument in her essay. Her examples did seem a bit lacking. She could have described them a bit more, but it was sufficient enough to get a main point across. Again, she does not reiterate her point about the lamps being the symbol for masking flaws. However, she does come back in the conclusion to tie the main idea together again. This essay may have received a 5-6.

Essay 3: This student starts off forgetting to underline her title of her novel and did not mention an author either. She also uses 'in my opinion' which is never something to put in an introduction. She was supposed to talk about the many aspects that the 'machette' symbolizes and how it affects the characters, but even in her introduction she only says "It symbolizes a higher level in power and the man who carried it was an intimidating man." That was her thesis. She then goes on to mentioning how the 'machette' was being used but none of the examples are solid ideas. Occasionally she goes off and gives extra details that do not pertain to the prompt. Her examples seem to be more of a 'matter of fact' kind of talk instead of showing the readers what she believes and why they support her argument. At the end, the students seems to have 2 conclusions. The first conclusion consists of multiple rhetorical questions aimed at the reader to dare the reader to refute her argument.  And by that point, the student doesn't even mention the word 'symbol' and does no connect the 1st convolution to the prompt. It seems at the end, she is trying to prove why the 'machette' gave Okonkwo power instead of why the 'machette' symbolized power. The second conclusion reiterates what was said in the 1st conclusion but makes far less sense. She goes to including 'w/' in her essay surprisingly. And even at the end, the student can be seen contradicting her self. The last sentence to her conclusion should have been at least tying all the part(s) together, however she did not and ends with "So it symbolizes pride. Most of all." This essay may have received a 2, or 3.

Tuesday, October 15, 2013

The American Dream Analysis and Summary

The American Dream

Author: Edward Albee
(He was orphaned at childhood, adopted by a rich family and a homosexual. His mother kept trying to get him to become presentable to society)

Type: Theater of the Absurd (maybe), Comedy, Drama

Setting: The living room of Daddy and Mommy's apartment.

Characters:
-Mommy:

  • Can be seen as the antagonist of the play. 
  • Babies Daddy and Grandma, telling them what to do and having them repeat what she just said like a child. 
  • Materialistic, constantly searching  for 'satisfaction'
  • Epitome of a bad mother. 
  • Needs power over people
  • Gender role swap with Daddy
-Daddy :
  • Constantly needs reassurance from Mommy about his masculinity
  • Has been reduced to a child-like state, repeating what Mommy says and talked to like a child
  • Has changed genders through surgery. 
  • Like Mommy he is also chasing the new American Dream and wants 'satisfaction'. 
  • Gender role swap with Mommy
-Grandma:
  • Grandma is able to travel from inside to play to the audience
  • Symbolizes the 'Old American Dream' and it's values
  • Only character 'acting' in the play
  • Opens the door (physically) to the New American Dream
  • Wisest character
-Young Man:
  • Represents values of the New American Dream
  • Is the twin of Mommy and Daddy's bumble
  • Hallow shell. Pretty on the outside but no inside
  • Becomes the new child for Mommy and Daddy
  • Is able to interact with Grandma outside the play
  • Is the 'satisfaction' for both Mommy and Daddy
Plot:
Mommy and Daddy start out sitting across from each other waiting for someone (and they don't know who or what they're waiting for). Mommy tells her short story of her trip to buy a hat, where we start to understand what the characters are like. Grandma comes in with a bunch of boxes, each nicely wrapped. We later find out that the boxes hold all the values of the Old American Dream. Grandma complains about being old and Mommy and Daddy complain about Grandma's bickering. Mrs. Barker ends up being the person they were waiting for and they can't figure out why she's there. There's a lot of sexual references thrown around between Daddy, Mommy and Mrs. Barker. After much confusion, Grandma finally reveals the history between Mommy, Daddy, Mrs. Barker and the bumble. And it is revealed that Mrs. Barker was supposed to come and 'replace' the bumble that just died. The Young Man knocks on the door looking for a job, and Grandma gives him the job of being the new bumble. However, no one seems to remember what the bumble looked like and comment on how Young Man/The American Dream looks familiar. So Mrs. Barker's case is solved, Mommy and Daddy are both happy, and Grandma leaves and joins the audience. Everyone's happy and 'satisfied' in the end. 

Narrative:
There isn't quite a narrator in the drama, until the very end when Grandma decides to join the audience. Albee uses the character dialogue to move the drama along. However, you can hear Albee's opinions loud and clear through out the play. He mocks the new materialistic world and the shallowness of the new generation. 

Style:
~Point of View- The play is set in third person with character dialogue to  tell the story. However, at the very end, the point of view changes so that Grandma is telling the story. 
~Tone- The tone of the piece is very dark from all the incest and violence physically to the imagery shown with the bumble. However, the tone is also mocking the current American society.
~Imagery- As I mentioned above, the imagery was especially during the part with the abuse of the bumble. His body parts were 'cut' off and from only that imagery you could tell what it may have symbolized. Ex: the cutting off of tongue means he doesn't speak, no guts, just that, and the cutting off of hands, he couldn't feel anymore. Albee uses imagery to show rather tell what characters are feeling.
~Symbolism- There was definitely a lot of symbolism put into the play. The symbolism of the abuse of the bumble is above and Grandma's boxes were brought up a lot. They symbolized the values of the old american dream packed and delivered out of the play. Grandma herself symbolizes the values of the old american dream because she isn't this materialistic, hallow person with no feelings. The Young Man represented the values of the new American Dream. His feelings from his twin have made him a hallow being, something perfect on the outside  but feeling-less on the inside. This version of the American Dream only cares for materialistic values. The Young Man even says that the'll do anything for money. 

Quotes:
Daddy: "Because it was empty." (Pg 66)- At this part, the characters have been talking about all the pretty boxes wrapped by Grandma and how Mommy used to bring it to school for her lunch but she would't open it. People thought it was empty. It can be interpreted as Grandma made the new American Dream. She made the hallow box/shell of a person. Grandma would fill it with chicken and her dinner from last night, but Mommy just gave it back (gave back those values) and ate the other children's chocolate cake and food (took new values, ones that meant close to nothing- they gave the food out of pity). Everyone viewed the box as empty, as in empty of values. 

Grandma: "...My sacks are empty, the fluid in my eyeballs is all caked on the inside edges, my spine is made of sugar candy, I breathe ice; but you don't hear me complain...that's because old people are gnarled and sagged and twisted into the shape of a complaint." (Pg 82-83) - At the beginning of the quote, Grandma is talking about being old, ancient even. It represent the deterioration of the old american dream. The old american dream is physically dying. Also, in the second part, Grandma being physically twisted can be taken as mentally twisted, as in unstable. The new generation is viewing the old american dream as unstable, and dying. Again, the idea of crippling of bodies is expressed in the quote. 

Theme:
Albee's American Dream warns that the current generation of Americans has gutted the heart and soul of traditional American values and replaces them with a materialistic longing to acquire complete satisfaction. 

The American Dream is the title to this play, but seeing how absurd the play is, Albee is mocking the american dream by making it the label of absurdity. The tone is dark and often violence and deformity can be seen as symbolism in the play. It usually represents the lack of feelings the characters inhibit and it's harm to the old american dream (gutting the heart and soul). And from the plot, we definitely know just how materialistic each character is. The Young Man / The American Dream will do anything for money, even if it meant being the next child of the people who murdered your twin. Babies aren't made from love anymore, they are bought, and if their love can't be bought, then they are neglected. The old american values that Grandma had had been destroyed and given back to Grandma (quote #1) while the new generation goes for the newer, prettier elements. In the end of the play, the American Dream literally replaces Grandma when she walks out of the play and all characters forget about her and welcomes the new american dream.   

Sunday, October 13, 2013

Closed Reading Sunday, October 13

'Fat letters' From Schools to Parents are Wrong


Schools used to be a social center for strictly learning, but now, according to Ruben Navarrette, the schools are unnecessarily controlling student diets and weights. Ruben is against policies of many states that take heights and weights to calculate BMIs and then sent to parents. Ruben's voice can be heard loud and clear with his use of diction, syntax, and language. 

Diction is such an important part to hearing Ruben's voice shine in his article. For example, "hocus-pocus" isn't a word you often read while browsing through CNN, but Ruben uses it to describe dietitians' methods of labeling students by their BMIs. Ruben doesn't use words like "method", instead, he chose "hocus-pocus" to bring on a tone of immaturity, unprofessional-ism, and an overall tone of disapproval. Not only that, but "Schools have been slapping labels on students..."  really gets the point across to readers that labeling students is harmful. Schools are not simple labeling students in Ruben's opinion, they're SLAPPING labels on students, making the action sound harmful and painful to students. Ruben made sure to carefully choose his words to create such disapproving tones throughout his article.

Not only is diction important, but Ruben's use of syntax helps readers feel his emotions. Throughout the article, short and or fragmented sentences can be found to emphasize ideas such as, "Fat letters.", "They had a point.", and "for mentally retarded." Just from a simple sentence, ("And what do students call these notes? "Fat letters.") readers can hear Ruben's emphasis on the name of the notes and it's importance. Ruben also uses a series of rhetorical questions to get readers to see the irony and hear his sarcasm.  ("Schools can't afford foreign language courses, sports programs or music classes. But they found funds for dieticians?") Lastly, Ruben uses the -ing form of verbs constantly to show it's presence forcefully. He mentions that schools "are receiving letters regarding something that really isn't a school's business" which shows how prevalent it is in people's lives at the moment and it's urgency. Just through syntax alone, readers can note Ruben's disapproving and critical tone. 

However, disapproving and critical aren't' the only tones heard throughout the article. I must compliment Ruben on his use of language. I'm not saying he chose to swear every other sentence; there wasn't a single swear word in the article. In fact, Ruben chose to use simple words and sentences casually to get his point across. While Ruben was being persuasive, his casual choice of words allowed readers to relate and understand him instead of just hear an argument. Furthermore, his use of the rhetoric as sarcasm allows the readers to sit back and laugh, making Ruben seem to be the better guy. He's not talking at you, digging around facts like a lawyer (no offense to anyone...), he's talking with you, and laughing with you too. He uses similar sentence structure for sentences, but changes up words for emphasis in his comparisons. "Many educators today might have a handle on math, science and reading. But they're flunking compassion, empathy, tact and sensitivity." Again, he almost sounds comedic, like you could add  'ba-dum tss" at the end. But we all know it's not funny, that Ruben is actually quite serious about the issue when he follows up these moments with a serious reality. 

Ruben uses a mix of diction, syntax and language to successfully portray his disapproval but also sincere plead for understanding of the current 'fat letters' issue. His mixture of serious and comedic moments allow the readers to get a feel for his character and tone in the article making readers feel compelled to side with this author. 

Sunday, September 29, 2013

Response to Course Material Sep 29th


Reading The American Dream by Edward Albee really made me look at humans in a different light. Right after listening to the play read out loud, I turned to my friend and said "I don't get it." There's no point to this story. But boy was I wrong.

Our discussions started out small, mostly asking, "Wait, was the baby actually killed?" or "Why couldn't the characters find rooms in their own apartment?" But the small answers led to big revelations. Small ideas like the bumble having it's hands and tongue cut off grew into new ideas. The pain felt by The American Dream were in all the same spots the bumble was feeling pain. We connected the bumble as being The American Dreams's long lost twin. But seeing how much Mommy loves The American Dream and how dense and hallow The American Dream is, we saw what Mommy truly wanted. She wanted a bumble that was hollow, devoid of feelings and emotions, thus concluding that Mommy was chasing the American Dream all along. The american dream that is too materialistic. Honestly, I'm not sure how long it would have taken me to arrive at this conclusion were it not for the class discussions. But some things that did help were the class handouts about absurdest plays and types of comedy. From reading those two handout, I was able to label the play and recognize certain elements of low comedy and farce attached to the story. Our discussion on DIDLS (Diction, Imagery, Details, Language, and Syntax) allowed us to pick apart the play, piece by piece to find the hidden meanings. I always thought of the American Dream was to have a nice house in the suburbs, with a loving husband, two kids, a white picket fence surrounding your daisies and a Ford Model-T. I didn't realize that there were different takes on the American Dream compared to the description given to all of us in our history books. I realized through our discussion that authors don't put details in a book just because it was random, they were all there to tell a bigger story for the readers.

I ended up google-ing Edward Albee and found that he had incorporated his life into his play. He was raised in an orphanage until he was adopted into a rich family. He constantly disobeyed his mother. She had wanted him to be 'respectable' to society while he wanted to hang out with artists and homosexuals. Just thinking about it now, Albee probably felt like the bumble. He couldn't do as he wanted in his childhood. His parents were constantly trying to change him to fit into an acceptable society. He as later thrown out of his house and disregarded by his parents, much like the bumble. His realization of conforming to society, materialism/consumerism comes from his life living with his rich adoptive parents.

Albee emphasized, but condemns this idea of satisfaction and consumerism. The little story with the beige and wheat hat reminded me of the lifestyles that people are living in today. Kids get an Iphone 4S on Christmas and then they heard about the Iphone 5S in school the next week. Then what do the kids start thinking? "But I wanted the IPHONE 5S!" And of course, you get the grandmother in the background saying, "back in my day, we didn't have phones to complain about." The American Dream made me realize that he was mocking this so called American Dream. For our generation, the American Dream is probably to own a fortune 500 company at the age of 25, later get a good looking spouse, own a dog/cat and 2 children, drive a Porsche to pick up your children from school and own multiple million-dollar houses. But as Albee had emphasized, what happened to playing football in the backyard with your two boys and baking cookies with your grandma? The American Dream has evolved to the point that feeling are no longer a part of this American Dream. It has only the name to show, but not the filling to hold it up.

Both my parents came to America 20 years ago to live a better life, so they are like Grandma. They are the pioneers who headed out west to a new and unfamiliar life. They had to work hard for every penny. One time, I asked for a smartphone , but was rejected. At that time I didn't understand. Everyone else had a phone back in middle school and I still had a flip phone in high school. But guilt started forming as we discussed Albee's reason to writing The American Dream. I am that new generation, chasing that new American Dream (mentioned above ^). To be honest, I do care more than I should about what society thinks of me. I was banned from wearing makeup because my friends shouldn't care how pretty I am. They need to look beyond that and into what I'm truly made of, like Grandma's day old cake. I felt that Grandma really did come out of the play and talked to me personally, wanting me to understand that this play isn't 'pointless'. I can now understand why my parents believe what they believe. I really hope The American Dream touched others' lives just as it did mine.

Sunday, September 22, 2013

Open Prompt (Part I) September 22

AP English Literature and Composition 2006 Question 3

Country Setting as a Source of Values

Essay #1:
Score: 8
Right off the bat, the student starts off answering the prompt in the first few sentences, even going on to mentioning how most writers portray the values of a countryside and challenges that common view. He/she uses Jane Austen's Persuasion to specifically address and argue his/her point in the essay.  And just from the introduction paragraph, we know the student sees the country side's "nurturing, virtuous, and peaceful quality". Although there are some punctuation errors (such as using & instead of 'and') ; and run-on sentences, they only have a minor effect on the quality of the argument. All three body paragraphs supported and went back to the prompt by talking about each different value backed with evidence. The use of transitions between paragraphs also help keep her essay flowing between ideas. The organization makes it easy for readers to pinpoint the certain arguments are. The author also ended with a strong conclusion  by reiterating the argument. However, she does not bring together all the ideas in the end by restating her three points to make her conclusion stronger.

Essay #2:
Score: 6
The student does not start off by answering the prompt, but waits until the end of the introduction to tell readers that the two settings are the countryside and the city. He/she does pick examples from a specific source, the Importance of Being Ernest. However, the examples in the introduction aren't answering the prompt clearly about how the countryside develops values. He/she explains why the use of the two settings, the countryside and the city, make the story a comedy. The three paragraphs don't support the prompt. The only thing being explained is the confusion in the story with the two settings to create a comedy. The student gives details, necessary and sometimes unrelated, and almost summarizes the story for readers instead of picking out the details to help support his/her point. Even in the student's conclusion, the only element argued was the comedic confusion and the prompt about values in the countryside were never explained. The essay would have been a much better fit for a different prompt.  

Essay #3:
Score: 4
The student's introduction, however short, does answer the prompt vaguely. His/her use of literary vocabulary does not always prove his understanding of them (ex: syllogism). He/she never once brings up the words 'countryside' nor does he talk about values later on in the essay. The student argues that characters were excused from their own stupidity because the author uses the setting (the South) as a scapegoat instead of admitting the characters have the flaw of ignorance.  The student automatically assumes the readers understood the South to be the countryside. There is a lack of developed ideas to support ideas within the essay, and a lack of details and explanation. The organization of the essay is somewhat messy and according to his/her explanation of the piece, the student should have chosen a different literary work to argue the prompt. The student seems to use 'big' words to make his piece sound elevated, when in fact, it does the opposite when he uses pompous words followed by extremely simple sentences. And in the end, the conclusion does summarize some of his/her points but does not answer the prompt. 

Sunday, September 15, 2013

Closed Reading Sunday, September 15

Losing my father's smile: The devastation of Bell's palsy




            It isn't often that you feel tears running down your face after hearing about a case of Bell's palsy all the way in New York. It's sad, but why aren't you crying right now? It really depends on how the author conveys the story. Too often we've heard the mono-toned news reporters on Fox telling us the latest headlines, and that's how we end up reading our news too. But Harrison Golden is different. His choice of diction, details, and syntax really create a story for us to live in.

            Harrison was only 9 when his father developed Bell's palsy. Harrison's father couldn't smile like he used to; it paralyzed half his face soon after that.  "Dad paused our catch to sip from a nearby water fountain. When the mother and child neared, he politely leaned into the stroller, waved and gave the baby his best smile. But because the Bell's palsy still lingered, his grin looked more like a smirk. The mother found his smile condescending. She ogled at him for a second or two, then rushed her stroller away." Harrison explains the severity of the issue using great diction. We didn't see a grumpy man stick his head into a baby's stroller to give his best evil smile. Harrison uses 'politely' to quickly establish what kind of man his father was. Harrison's father even 'waved' and gave the baby his 'best smile'. It wasn't any smile. His father was sincerely trying. But instead of a half smile, we hear Harrison use the word 'smirk'. That's exactly how the mother saw the smile as she 'ogled' at him, not 'looked' at him, but 'ogled' at him as if he had something wrong with him. Just from a few sentences, we know the sad truth of a  kind man is misinterpreted as 'condescending' because of a disability. 

            Diction isn't the only thing telling us a great story. Harrison incorporates detailed accounts of his own life. "Breaking the promise I made myself was tempting, but I couldn't let Dad not smile alone. I didn't care how hard I needed to bite my lip. I had my critics. Kids would call me "Frowny the Dwarf." (It didn't help that I was merely 3-foot-10 at age nine.) " Details such as biting his lip and being called 'Frowny the Dwarf' really add sympathy to a story. Not only did his father's life change, Harrison's life was turned around too. Any news reporter could have just said that "Harrison refused to smile until he saw his father's smile." That would have been seen as stubborn. But Harrison describes his own suffering physically, which reflected his hurt for his father emotionally. Being only 3-foot-10 creates an image of a small little boy who is helpless to defend himself.

            Harrison's use of syntax gives his story a certain tone and quality. He often uses short, fragmented sentences like "Then he called Dad." to convey emphasis or a distressed idea. There were few longer, poetic sentences because this story wasn't meant to be seen as a piece of writing disconnected from his childhood. The sentence structures are simple, and easily understood in a narrative format, almost as if he was speaking as a fourth grader, creating an innocence that reporters would not be able to convey.
           
            Harrison, such a small boy, shared with the world his suffering and sadness towards his father. However, I  forgot to mention this; Harrison is now a senior in college and his father was diagnosed back in 2001. Harrison does such a great job with the usage of diction, details and syntax to suck the readers into the past; into his story. As readers, we forgot that Harrison is no longer in fourth grade, and we feel his pain, innocence, and longing to see his father's smile again. Harrison's great combination rewound the clock to show America a side to his family that no reporter would have been able to do. 

Monday, September 2, 2013

Practice Questions (Chapter 3)

Ok, where to start. Let's starts with my weaknesses. Old texts with complex words that aren't used in daily English always trips me up, along with the wording. However, that isn't my biggest concern. After a few times of reading through any complicated wording, I start to understand the written meaning. The symbolism kills me though. In the Sample Questions, I had a hard time deciphering what each character and action may have meant. It happened again in Practice 1, except this time I also had issues with normal everyday vocabulary. Half the time I was wondering what a 'Nautilus' was and what kind of shell was THE shell in the poem. Luckily there is something called 'Google' and I have learned from that. Back to the old text problem. In Practice 3, I was quite limited in knowledge on the Bible and any Roman mythology (I prefer Greek). The poems I find easy are the ones that are relatively similar to contemporary writing. Practice 4 I got every question right....except #10. Basically any question that comes up about the type of poetry or type of rhyme, I miss. Looks like I should invest some time in the vocabulary department.

Saturday, August 17, 2013

Diagnostic Test

We all know what diagnostic tests do to our confidence, and in this case, it was not pretty. Ok, maybe it's pretty if you're looking at all the red squiggly lines going through most of my answers, but that's beside the point.

Reading and analyzing literature has never been my forte. To get straight to the point, I'm a slow reader. When I took the diagnostic test, I set my timer and skimmed the first poem, and I did not understand a single word. Towards the end I was thinking, 'What does a compass have to do with anything in this poem? Heck what is this poem even about?' I came into the test thinking I had to skim every passage like I do in the ACT so I could finish within the allowed time. After thoroughly reading the poem a second and third time, I then realized the main point and it had been sitting there, staring at me the entire time.

The second passage was the very beginning of Pride and Prejudice, one of my favorite literature novels. This section, I decided to skim. The questions seemed simple to me, knowing that I've already analyzed the entire book last year, I was more confident. However, when checking over my answers, I came across a few explanations (from the Peterson's AP English Literature & Composition) like this: "Choice (C) is not correct because the Bennets have not yet met Mr. Bingley, so a conflict cannot have developed." (P.68) I hadn't taken into account that the answers would only be based on the passage that was given, not the entire book.

At the end of the multiple choice, I decided that I was done. I should have gone back and checked my answers, re-read a couple sections, but I knew my time was limited. I checked my timer, and I still had 22 minutes and 42 seconds left! While writing this, I'm still mad at myself for not going back and re-reading the narrative passage. It's not a passage I had to analyze like a poem, so I could have just read it more carefully and gotten the answers easily. It also became apparent to me after calculating my score that I need to go back and review my vocabulary. To be honest, I don't remember the differences between a lyric, elegy, ode, and a sonnet. (Sorry Mrs. Patnoude!)

So I didn't read all the directions carefully, and I ended up taking the essay portion as well. Whoops. But I can tell you this; the essay portion is harder than the multiple choice, and there isn't nearly enough time to write a detailed essay in 40 minutes.

Overall, my experience with this diagnostic test was less than desirable, but it really allowed me to see what I'll have to face for the next 7 months or so. I'm going to have to work hard, but hopefully it'll pay off in the future.