Ok good news? About 9 more weeks of school!!! That means 9 more dreaded Mondays!! (Not counting Spring Break, I'm too lazy to calculate that in)
The bad news? 7 weeks until APs....
So the last time I wrote a Response to Course Material blog was..February 16th, which means it has been exactly 1 month, and a lot has happened. We came back from President's day weekend and practiced multiple choice for the AP while Holmes took us aside to talk to us about our essays. We wrote that essay a while ago, so most of us don't even remember what happened that day. But Holmes gave some good tips earlier but we may not have taken them all into account since she scolded us for the Open Prompts she read on our blogs. But having spoken to Holmes individually really helped me understand what the goal to the essay is. I was pretty happy to have received a 7 on the closed prompt we wrote in class (then edited and shared with Holmes) but then I realized that a 7 with 2 days to revise and less pressure probably equates to a 4 on the actual AP, so I guess I have a lot more work to do. It makes me feel like a kid again, learning how to ride a bike with training wheels on. After that has been accomplished, the hard part is taking the training wheels off. Yikes.
Sadly we said our goodbyes to Ros and Guil. It seemed to me that the more discussions we had, the more confusing the book got. I wasn't in lit on Thursday and Friday, so I have a different theme statement than the unanimous ones from the previous hours and the one from my own how. I ended up with the idea that Stoppard wanted the audience to know that they are not in a play, and therefore should take control of their own boats. I was glad to have realized that others wrote a similar theme statement, but some argued that Stoppard thought that fate does exist and even you can't do anything about it. Funny how even in the same class, having the same discussions, we come up with polar opposite ideas. In the beginning of the year with The American Dream, we all seemed to agree on one idea and that was it. There was little argument to it. I remember how we used to wrack our brains trying to think of a theme for The American Dream and get a good understanding of the book, but looking back on it, we were either oblivious to details or we have just gotten much better at understand them.
Finally we moved on to Ceremony, at least for a short while. The presentations we read/watched in class proved to be useful. They allowed me to experience the culture and beliefs of the Native Americans. However, I still find Ceremony very hard to understand. What gets me the most are the movement of time. I can't tell if a certain part that I'm reading is happening before, right after, or way past that unless I've read the section about 3 times. But the question I was dying to know while I was reading was, what happens if someone in AP Lit happens to be Japanese? I noticed at the beginning of the book, there were some pretty racist remarks towards the Japanese, and having relatives who have fought against the Japanese, even I felt that it was a bit too much. Wouldn't you be offended if you went to study abroad in England and you were required to read a novel that spoke ill of the American?
Recently we've been working a lot on placing literature in a certain lens. Apparently 1st and 2nd hour have been doing a great job and have been coming upon many revelations, but 6th hour doesn't seem to be getting anywhere. Don't kill me Mrs. Holmes, but I think what is happening is that a lot of us don't quite understand what certain lenses mean and its purpose. I was also wondering if certain lenses can not pertain to certain books. In one of our discussions with The American Dream, I remember someone saying, "Let's not do that lens. I don't think it applies to this book", but going thorough the lenses again, I realize they can all be a way to view The American Dream, unless I'm missing one. But hopefully we get more time to go over these lenses, because I have a feeling these will become a big part of our class later.
Sunday, March 16, 2014
Sunday, March 9, 2014
Open Prompt (Part II) March 9th
Prompt: In many works of literature, past events can affect, positively or negatively, the present activities, attitudes, or values of a character. Choose a novel or play in which a character must contend with some aspect of the past, either personal or societal. Then write an essay in which you show how the character’s relationship to the past contributes to the meaning of the work as a whole.
Mary Shelly's Frankenstein narrates the story of a monster created by Victor Frankenstein. Frankenstein's monster was originally created due to Frankenstein's own curiosity. However, The Monster's appearance is so frightening that Frankenstein abandons his own creation. Unfortunately, society also mistreats The Monster due to prejudice based on his outer appearance. The mistreatment that The Monster faces in the past lead him to become bitter and vengeful. Shelly contrasts the negative effects of the past on The Monster to his once gentle and kind nature to emphasize the true nature of human beings.
Victor Frankenstein, a genius scientist and alchemist, creates a monster out of dead body parts sewn together and a spark of electricity. The Monster is then born into the world only to be rejected by his own 'father' due to his horrendous appearance. The unrequited love causes The Monster to realize his own hideous appearance. The Monster tries and tries again to get the attention of Victor only to be resented and lied to. These very first events causes the inherently good natured, and kind Monster to be fill with anger, hurt, and vengence. The lack of love for The Monster during the very early stages of his life teaches The Monster to become hateful and murderous.
Not only did Victor, The Monster's own creator, reject him, but society as a whole rejected him based of previous prejudice. The Monster is a good hearted person at the beginning of the novel; he saves a girl from drowning and anonymously helps a family get through a tough winter. However, society, much like Victor, decides to harm The Monster solely based on his frightening appearance and his large stature which resembles a monster. After being shot at and rejected by the very family he learned to love, The Monster realizes that no one will be willing to accept him; not society and not even his own creator. All of the disgust and prejudice directed towards The Monster early on in his life makes him become vengeful, killing the dearest people to Victor, and therefore a murderer.
A once kind hearted and innocent creation is turned into a monster from the loveless and prejudice world he lives in. Shelly uses these mistreatment to justify the belief that humans, like The Monster, are born naturally good but become cruel from the effects of society as a whole. The kind hearted Monster represents the kind nature of human beings at the beginning of their life journey, and the final vengeful product of The Monster shows the effects society has on humans, and how the past can define the person one is today.
Thursday, March 6, 2014
Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Summary and Analysis
Author: Tom Stoppard (Also directed the movie)
Settings: Nowhere, In a forest, In a play, In Hamlet (the play)
Characters:
Plot Summary:
Act I: The play starts out with Rosencrantz and Guildenstern in the middle of nowhere, literally without a setting, tossing coins. Rosencrantz is the one who is constantly winning all the coins because it is constantly showing up as heads. Guil questions the reasons for the unnatural probability while Ros chooses to just go with the flow and not question his luck. Guil is on a role and after questioning probability, he goes on to asking Ros about his earliest memory. Guil is the one who remembers that they were "sent" for by a messenger whereas Ros almost immediately forgets the question let alone remembers much else in the past. While the two are still on their unknown journey, they start to test the boundaries again with recognizing an audience and hearing music. Ros and Guil come upon the Tragedians and the Player. They say they want to perform something for them but at the expense of a few gold coins. Ros and Guil, while introducing themselves, mix up their identities. The Player describes the types of performances that they show, and we realize they are sexual performances. Guil is actually repulsed by the idea while Ros seems pretty intrigued. Ros decides to give them one coin and offer a bet. The Player says heads, and the coin lands on heads again. Then Guil calls heads and he wins. Later the Player calls heads, and he wins. The Player finally calls tails but Guil claims it is heads. They then go on to betting if their birth year doubled would be even or odd. The Player soon realizes that any number doubled is always even, so the Player gives Guil Alfred as payment. Instead, Guil wants to see a play instead for payment. The Player reveals that he never gets out of costume or character, or walks off the stage. At this point, we also see that the coin from earlier was actually tails, and the Player did win, and payment was not supposed to have been necessary. At this point, Ros and Guil have become sucked into the play and they are given actual lines for the times when they are "onstage" "performing". When they are offstage, they are confused and want to go home. However, they do 'recognize' Hamlet as an old friend and try to help him solve his madness. The main plot of Hamlet (the very beginning at Elsinore) is occurring while Ros and Guil are trying to figure out what is going on with the lack of information they have gathered.
Act II: Act II begins with Ros and Guil still trying to conclude whether Hamlet is indeed mad. As they try to figure that out, they also contemplate the existence of the wind and we see an almost sexual relationship between Ros and Guil. The Player, Ros and Guil end up discussing the play they will be doing The Murder of Gonzago. The Player tells Ros and Guil to act naturally, like they would normally do since it is apparently natural to be lost and confused in the real world. This leads to Ros and Guil contemplating the meaning of death and what actually happens. Guil is left saddened because he realizes he has not done anything of impact yet.The play they are putting on is about to start and the natural story of Hamelt is occurring here. The Murder of Gonzago is the play within the play. Guil and Ros keeps getting confused and doing the wrong things at the wrong time in the play As the play ends, The Player tells Ros and Guil that characters who intent to die, must die, because it is already predestined. The Play keeps going and when they get to the part where the two spies that were to escort Hamlet to his death in England, they recognize the two spies to have the same clothing as they do, but do not realize that they are the two spies. As the Player and Guil talk about the deaths that need to happen, Guil disagrees that death can be acted. The scene then opens up again with Ros and Guil finding themselves in the position of the dead spies. They get up and dispute the correct direction for west and encounter Hamlet. We then learn that Hamlet is to be escorted to England.
Act III: At the very beginning, the play opens up with Ros and Guil figuring out that they are on a dark boat at sea. Guil mentions liking boats becasue of the freedom but also lack of it too. Ros and Guil end up frustrated at not knowing what is going on, and what to do. They finally recall receiving a letter and that it is supposed to come to England along with Hamlet. After reading the letter, Ros decided he does not want to be an accomplice but Guil says that death should not be something feared because it is the unknown. While Ros and Guil are sleeping, Hamlet switches the letters so that Hamlet is not to be executed, but Ros and Guil are. A new scene appears and not long after, pirates charge the ship and Hamlet goes missing. The Player, Guil and Ros are still there. Guil is confused and in anguish because he cannot understand the point of life. So the two decide to act out what will happen in England, and in doing so, they read the letter and realize that now it is a different letter asking for the death of Ros and Guil. The Tragedians come on stage and after arguing about death the The Player, Guil grabs the Player's knife and "kills' him. But the death is fake. They ask to see more, intrigued at it's life like qualities. They see actors for Ros and Guil die and they too soon realize that they have to die. Ros vanishes and Guil is deeply troubled by his lack of control over his own end, and there has to have been something he could have done to change the ending. He concluded, though, that he will have next time, and is glad that this is at least over.
Theme: Tom Stoppard's Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead emphasizes the differences between real life and fiction to suggest that, one must take control of their life instead of letting others control your life.
In Stoppard's play, he is constantly reminding the audience/readers that what they are reading is in fact, a play. Ros and Guil even acknowledge an audience a few times and the constant reminder that the characters are actors are a reminder to us that what we are reading is a play. Stoppard explains through the Player that a play has a predestined ending that cannot be changed by the characters. Ironically, Ros and Guil, at the very end of the play, regret not having grasped the ship/moment to change their own 'lives' when they had the chance. By adding this section, Stoppard is stating clearly the differences between life and fiction, and the possibility of taking control of your own boat.
Tone: Although this is a comedy that makes the audience laugh, it is a very dark comedy which makes us laugh at the most inappropriate times. The play also includes more than just the comical nonsense that Ros and Guil do, it also shows the darkness of eternal death and the lack of control over one's 'life'.
Symbols: A big symbol in this play is the boat. Ros and Guil originally thought that being on the boat was great, that they could just sit back and relax while someone else took control over their lives. However, that turned out to the be a big mistake because they are no longer in control over their own decisions/their boat.
It is also believed that England could also represent Heaven because ultimately, that is where fate is taking them, and the coin is a representation of the failure of logic.
Quote:
Ros: "Life in a box is better than no life at all, I expect. You'd have a chance at least. You could lie there thinking: Well, at least I'm not dead." PG 71
This quote is talking about having a life that is restricted, and not free. Ros thinks that at least you could have a chance of escaping the box to become free. Anything is possible while you are still alive. Ironically, Ros and Guil do not have real 'lives' and they are not real people. They are only characters, so they cannot escape the box. They have no freedom; their fates have already been written. And in the end, they ironically (again) they welcome death as opposed to the eternal suffering they will have to face by being un-dead.
"Ros: I wish I was dead. (Considers the drop.) I could jump over the side. that would put a spoke in their wheel.
Guil: Unless they're counting on it.
Ros: I shall remain on board. That'll put a spoke in their wheel. " PG 177
This is a series of contradicting ideas. Ros thinks that making a jump would be a decision that he has made for himself, even if it is the last. However, Guil thinks they are bound to fate, and that could just be another decision destined for them. Ironically, Ros decides to stay on board to defy fate, but ends up fulfilling it instead. It's almost as if it's Stoppard's way of telling us that characters in a story can never escape from the predestined lives they must 'live'.
Settings: Nowhere, In a forest, In a play, In Hamlet (the play)
Characters:
- Guildenstern:
- Always testing the limits of the play/stage
- Always trying to understand his life and the world around it
- Identity swap with Rosencrantz often
- Childhood friend of Hamlet/ Good friends (or something more...) with Rozencrantz
- Rosencrantz:
- Very one dementional
- Static character
- Very carefree
- childhood friend of Hamlet
- Good friends with Guildenstern (or something more...)
- The Player:
- "Leader" of the tragedians
- Mysterious but witty
- Seems to have the answers for Ros and Guil
- Pimp
- Tragedians:
- Actors of the Player's play (all men)
- Also sexual entertainers
- Characters from Hamlet:
- Hamlet, Ophelia, Polonius, Claudius, etc.
- The original characters from Shakespeare's Hamlet
- All have scripted lines and act as they do and should from the original play
Plot Summary:
Act I: The play starts out with Rosencrantz and Guildenstern in the middle of nowhere, literally without a setting, tossing coins. Rosencrantz is the one who is constantly winning all the coins because it is constantly showing up as heads. Guil questions the reasons for the unnatural probability while Ros chooses to just go with the flow and not question his luck. Guil is on a role and after questioning probability, he goes on to asking Ros about his earliest memory. Guil is the one who remembers that they were "sent" for by a messenger whereas Ros almost immediately forgets the question let alone remembers much else in the past. While the two are still on their unknown journey, they start to test the boundaries again with recognizing an audience and hearing music. Ros and Guil come upon the Tragedians and the Player. They say they want to perform something for them but at the expense of a few gold coins. Ros and Guil, while introducing themselves, mix up their identities. The Player describes the types of performances that they show, and we realize they are sexual performances. Guil is actually repulsed by the idea while Ros seems pretty intrigued. Ros decides to give them one coin and offer a bet. The Player says heads, and the coin lands on heads again. Then Guil calls heads and he wins. Later the Player calls heads, and he wins. The Player finally calls tails but Guil claims it is heads. They then go on to betting if their birth year doubled would be even or odd. The Player soon realizes that any number doubled is always even, so the Player gives Guil Alfred as payment. Instead, Guil wants to see a play instead for payment. The Player reveals that he never gets out of costume or character, or walks off the stage. At this point, we also see that the coin from earlier was actually tails, and the Player did win, and payment was not supposed to have been necessary. At this point, Ros and Guil have become sucked into the play and they are given actual lines for the times when they are "onstage" "performing". When they are offstage, they are confused and want to go home. However, they do 'recognize' Hamlet as an old friend and try to help him solve his madness. The main plot of Hamlet (the very beginning at Elsinore) is occurring while Ros and Guil are trying to figure out what is going on with the lack of information they have gathered.
Act II: Act II begins with Ros and Guil still trying to conclude whether Hamlet is indeed mad. As they try to figure that out, they also contemplate the existence of the wind and we see an almost sexual relationship between Ros and Guil. The Player, Ros and Guil end up discussing the play they will be doing The Murder of Gonzago. The Player tells Ros and Guil to act naturally, like they would normally do since it is apparently natural to be lost and confused in the real world. This leads to Ros and Guil contemplating the meaning of death and what actually happens. Guil is left saddened because he realizes he has not done anything of impact yet.The play they are putting on is about to start and the natural story of Hamelt is occurring here. The Murder of Gonzago is the play within the play. Guil and Ros keeps getting confused and doing the wrong things at the wrong time in the play As the play ends, The Player tells Ros and Guil that characters who intent to die, must die, because it is already predestined. The Play keeps going and when they get to the part where the two spies that were to escort Hamlet to his death in England, they recognize the two spies to have the same clothing as they do, but do not realize that they are the two spies. As the Player and Guil talk about the deaths that need to happen, Guil disagrees that death can be acted. The scene then opens up again with Ros and Guil finding themselves in the position of the dead spies. They get up and dispute the correct direction for west and encounter Hamlet. We then learn that Hamlet is to be escorted to England.
Act III: At the very beginning, the play opens up with Ros and Guil figuring out that they are on a dark boat at sea. Guil mentions liking boats becasue of the freedom but also lack of it too. Ros and Guil end up frustrated at not knowing what is going on, and what to do. They finally recall receiving a letter and that it is supposed to come to England along with Hamlet. After reading the letter, Ros decided he does not want to be an accomplice but Guil says that death should not be something feared because it is the unknown. While Ros and Guil are sleeping, Hamlet switches the letters so that Hamlet is not to be executed, but Ros and Guil are. A new scene appears and not long after, pirates charge the ship and Hamlet goes missing. The Player, Guil and Ros are still there. Guil is confused and in anguish because he cannot understand the point of life. So the two decide to act out what will happen in England, and in doing so, they read the letter and realize that now it is a different letter asking for the death of Ros and Guil. The Tragedians come on stage and after arguing about death the The Player, Guil grabs the Player's knife and "kills' him. But the death is fake. They ask to see more, intrigued at it's life like qualities. They see actors for Ros and Guil die and they too soon realize that they have to die. Ros vanishes and Guil is deeply troubled by his lack of control over his own end, and there has to have been something he could have done to change the ending. He concluded, though, that he will have next time, and is glad that this is at least over.
Theme: Tom Stoppard's Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead emphasizes the differences between real life and fiction to suggest that, one must take control of their life instead of letting others control your life.
In Stoppard's play, he is constantly reminding the audience/readers that what they are reading is in fact, a play. Ros and Guil even acknowledge an audience a few times and the constant reminder that the characters are actors are a reminder to us that what we are reading is a play. Stoppard explains through the Player that a play has a predestined ending that cannot be changed by the characters. Ironically, Ros and Guil, at the very end of the play, regret not having grasped the ship/moment to change their own 'lives' when they had the chance. By adding this section, Stoppard is stating clearly the differences between life and fiction, and the possibility of taking control of your own boat.
Tone: Although this is a comedy that makes the audience laugh, it is a very dark comedy which makes us laugh at the most inappropriate times. The play also includes more than just the comical nonsense that Ros and Guil do, it also shows the darkness of eternal death and the lack of control over one's 'life'.
Symbols: A big symbol in this play is the boat. Ros and Guil originally thought that being on the boat was great, that they could just sit back and relax while someone else took control over their lives. However, that turned out to the be a big mistake because they are no longer in control over their own decisions/their boat.
It is also believed that England could also represent Heaven because ultimately, that is where fate is taking them, and the coin is a representation of the failure of logic.
Quote:
Ros: "Life in a box is better than no life at all, I expect. You'd have a chance at least. You could lie there thinking: Well, at least I'm not dead." PG 71
This quote is talking about having a life that is restricted, and not free. Ros thinks that at least you could have a chance of escaping the box to become free. Anything is possible while you are still alive. Ironically, Ros and Guil do not have real 'lives' and they are not real people. They are only characters, so they cannot escape the box. They have no freedom; their fates have already been written. And in the end, they ironically (again) they welcome death as opposed to the eternal suffering they will have to face by being un-dead.
"Ros: I wish I was dead. (Considers the drop.) I could jump over the side. that would put a spoke in their wheel.
Guil: Unless they're counting on it.
Ros: I shall remain on board. That'll put a spoke in their wheel. " PG 177
This is a series of contradicting ideas. Ros thinks that making a jump would be a decision that he has made for himself, even if it is the last. However, Guil thinks they are bound to fate, and that could just be another decision destined for them. Ironically, Ros decides to stay on board to defy fate, but ends up fulfilling it instead. It's almost as if it's Stoppard's way of telling us that characters in a story can never escape from the predestined lives they must 'live'.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)