Sunday, September 15, 2013

Closed Reading Sunday, September 15

Losing my father's smile: The devastation of Bell's palsy




            It isn't often that you feel tears running down your face after hearing about a case of Bell's palsy all the way in New York. It's sad, but why aren't you crying right now? It really depends on how the author conveys the story. Too often we've heard the mono-toned news reporters on Fox telling us the latest headlines, and that's how we end up reading our news too. But Harrison Golden is different. His choice of diction, details, and syntax really create a story for us to live in.

            Harrison was only 9 when his father developed Bell's palsy. Harrison's father couldn't smile like he used to; it paralyzed half his face soon after that.  "Dad paused our catch to sip from a nearby water fountain. When the mother and child neared, he politely leaned into the stroller, waved and gave the baby his best smile. But because the Bell's palsy still lingered, his grin looked more like a smirk. The mother found his smile condescending. She ogled at him for a second or two, then rushed her stroller away." Harrison explains the severity of the issue using great diction. We didn't see a grumpy man stick his head into a baby's stroller to give his best evil smile. Harrison uses 'politely' to quickly establish what kind of man his father was. Harrison's father even 'waved' and gave the baby his 'best smile'. It wasn't any smile. His father was sincerely trying. But instead of a half smile, we hear Harrison use the word 'smirk'. That's exactly how the mother saw the smile as she 'ogled' at him, not 'looked' at him, but 'ogled' at him as if he had something wrong with him. Just from a few sentences, we know the sad truth of a  kind man is misinterpreted as 'condescending' because of a disability. 

            Diction isn't the only thing telling us a great story. Harrison incorporates detailed accounts of his own life. "Breaking the promise I made myself was tempting, but I couldn't let Dad not smile alone. I didn't care how hard I needed to bite my lip. I had my critics. Kids would call me "Frowny the Dwarf." (It didn't help that I was merely 3-foot-10 at age nine.) " Details such as biting his lip and being called 'Frowny the Dwarf' really add sympathy to a story. Not only did his father's life change, Harrison's life was turned around too. Any news reporter could have just said that "Harrison refused to smile until he saw his father's smile." That would have been seen as stubborn. But Harrison describes his own suffering physically, which reflected his hurt for his father emotionally. Being only 3-foot-10 creates an image of a small little boy who is helpless to defend himself.

            Harrison's use of syntax gives his story a certain tone and quality. He often uses short, fragmented sentences like "Then he called Dad." to convey emphasis or a distressed idea. There were few longer, poetic sentences because this story wasn't meant to be seen as a piece of writing disconnected from his childhood. The sentence structures are simple, and easily understood in a narrative format, almost as if he was speaking as a fourth grader, creating an innocence that reporters would not be able to convey.
           
            Harrison, such a small boy, shared with the world his suffering and sadness towards his father. However, I  forgot to mention this; Harrison is now a senior in college and his father was diagnosed back in 2001. Harrison does such a great job with the usage of diction, details and syntax to suck the readers into the past; into his story. As readers, we forgot that Harrison is no longer in fourth grade, and we feel his pain, innocence, and longing to see his father's smile again. Harrison's great combination rewound the clock to show America a side to his family that no reporter would have been able to do. 

2 comments:

  1. Kathy,
    Good job with the close reading of Losing my father's smile: The devastation of Bell's palsy. You had great examples to support your claims. The comparison of how the article was written compared to how the news is reported I thought was really interesting. I agree that when you listen to the news it is fairly monotone, even when reporting sad, negative, or even horrific events. I do think though you have to take into consideration that the news is made to be concise, while an article like this can be longer because it can focus on one issue. I think that that is partially why there is difference in the diction and details used and included. I agree that Harrison’s use of these techniques definitely help convey his message better and affect. You had a thorough analysis, good job. I was wondering do you think how news could be changed (techniques), to make it appear more connected and less distant and monotone?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Kathy,
    Your response is so articulate and concise. On the first paragraph on diction, I liked the points you addressed, but I think you should have looked at other sentences as well. The way that Harrison was able to paint a caring picture of his disabled dad is all thanks to diction. Word choice is essential in making someone who looks frightening appear harmless. Throughout the article, Harrison’s dad is addressed positively. From the description of how his smile impacted others to how he “lamented” over the loss of it; this further depicts Harrison’s father as everything but condescending and smirking. The details you pointed out also explain why I felt so compassionate for Harrison and his father; they struggled together. I liked your train of thought in your last few sentences of that paragraph, you were aware of Harrison’s writing style and message he was trying to convey, but that didn't inhibit your reaction. I think that you hit the nail on the head again on analyzing the syntax in that Harrison sounds innocent and friendly through his writing. This makes the reader feel compassion towards him while also hearing a child’s voice behind the article.

    ReplyDelete