AP English Literature and Composition 2006 Question 3
Country Setting as a Source of Values
Essay #1:
Score: 8
Score: 8
Right off the bat, the student starts off answering the prompt
in the first few sentences, even going on to mentioning how most writers
portray the values of a countryside and challenges that common view. He/she
uses Jane Austen's Persuasion to
specifically address and argue his/her point in the essay. And just from the introduction paragraph, we
know the student sees the country side's "nurturing, virtuous, and
peaceful quality". Although there are some punctuation errors (such as
using & instead of 'and') ; and run-on sentences, they only have a minor
effect on the quality of the argument. All three body paragraphs supported and
went back to the prompt by talking about each different value backed with
evidence. The use of transitions between paragraphs also help keep her essay
flowing between ideas. The organization makes it easy for readers to pinpoint
the certain arguments are. The author also ended with a strong conclusion by reiterating the argument. However, she does
not bring together all the ideas in the end by restating her three points to
make her conclusion stronger.
Essay #2:
Score: 6
Score: 6
The student does not start off by answering the prompt, but
waits until the end of the introduction to tell readers that the two settings
are the countryside and the city. He/she does pick examples from a specific
source, the Importance of Being Ernest. However,
the examples in the introduction aren't answering the prompt clearly about how
the countryside develops values. He/she explains why the use of the two
settings, the countryside and the city, make the story a comedy. The three
paragraphs don't support the prompt. The only thing being explained is the
confusion in the story with the two settings to create a comedy. The student
gives details, necessary and sometimes unrelated, and almost summarizes the
story for readers instead of picking out the details to help support his/her
point. Even in the student's conclusion, the only element argued was the
comedic confusion and the prompt about values in the countryside were never
explained. The essay would have been a much better fit for a different prompt.
Essay #3:
Score: 4
Score: 4
The student's introduction, however short, does answer the
prompt vaguely. His/her use of literary vocabulary does not always prove his
understanding of them (ex: syllogism). He/she never once brings up the words
'countryside' nor does he talk about values later on in the essay. The student argues
that characters were excused from their own stupidity because the author uses
the setting (the South) as a scapegoat instead of admitting the characters have
the flaw of ignorance. The student
automatically assumes the readers understood the South to be the countryside.
There is a lack of developed ideas to support ideas within the essay, and a
lack of details and explanation. The organization of the essay is somewhat
messy and according to his/her explanation of the piece, the student should
have chosen a different literary work to argue the prompt. The student seems to
use 'big' words to make his piece sound elevated, when in fact, it does the
opposite when he uses pompous words followed by extremely simple sentences. And
in the end, the conclusion does summarize some of his/her points but does not
answer the prompt.
Kathy,
ReplyDeleteYou did a good job reading the essays and responding to them. I thought your explanations for why each essay was good or not were thorough. For the first essay, you do a good job of reviewing the different components that are needed for a well written essay. You mention that the student has a strong conclusion but did not restate their three main points. I’m wondering if they have a strong conclusion if it is really even necessary because the purpose of a conclusion is to wrap up everything. I agree though if done correctly it is more likely to make the essay stronger. What did the first essay receive as a score? For the second essay, you point out the mistakes in the essay the very first one being that the essay really didn't fit the prompt. For the third essay, you explain that the student’s attempt to use “big words” to try to create an “elevated” actually hurt the student because simple sentences. Good job using what we learned in The Nuts and Bolts of College Writing and applying it to your review.
Kathy,
ReplyDeleteI agree with your feedback on the essays. The first essay was the best with three main points backed up by substantial evidence. You tend to focus on every aspect of the essay rather than just the content, which shows how carefully you read the essay while grasping the big picture. I struggled to figure out why I felt the second essay was inadequate. Reading the your response helped me realize the weaknesses of this piece. The essay went too in depth about comedy rather than values and did not answer the question. It would fit perfectly for another prompt; as you mentioned. The final essay was painful to read and while it is easy to get distracted by how bad it was, you were able to point to pieces of the essay that made it insufficient. For example you mentioned how the countryside wasn't even addressed and how values are ignored entirely. You also were able to point out the “pompous” language (Foster’s term) in this writer’s essay which shows your understanding of that style and the inappropriate use of elevated words. All your responses are very articulate and thoughtful, you’re going to ace the open prompt questions!