AP Literature and Composition 2004 Prompt Question #3
Prompt: Roland Barthes: "Literature is the questions minus the answer."
(I could not find an actual prompt question unless that was it.)
N. Essay #1: N's essay is put together extraordinarily well. N starts off with a strong introduction, however a bit wordy, proposing the question, "Is this the best of all possible worlds?" which answers the prompt. However, one minor flaw in the absence of the author included with the title, Candide. The body paragraphs at first seem to include too much unnecessary information and summarized the story rather than answering the prompt, but N uses this to his/her advantage and most of his/her summary became evidence. However, there are still a few unnecessary parts. Despite that, N always goes back to the prompt, reminding readers why the information is important. The language used in the essay is pretty sophisticated and little to no grammatical errors occurs. There are a few instances where N gets too repetitive with a specific word or phrase. The conclusion was solid, however, the use of The Prophet by Kahlil Gibrar seemed unnecessary and did nothing to the overall message in the essay. The AP grader gave N an 8 which is a very reasonable score.
J. Essay #2: J starts with a strong introduction with an reasonable central question: "What does it mean to be free?". However, simply stating that the novel "explor[es] the limits that slavery and civilization place upon the novel's characters." is a bit vague. The beginning of the J's essay starts out strong and seems to be headed towards the right direction, but slowly J moves further and further from his/her central question. J concluded the essay stating that both the characters were not actually free, but never defined what 'free' meant. The definition could be implied through the context of the essay, however, J just didn't have that push to answer the question all the way. The conclusion strayed so far from the central question that it answered a different question. J ended up explaining why freedom is limited because of society instead of saying what it meant to be free. J was had inconsistent grammatical errors such as fragmented sentences and spelling errors, however they do not distract the readers too much. According to the AP reader, J used a good source and knew Huckleberry Finn well, however they kept "skirts around this [the central question] important issue." J received a 6. The main goal is to always answer the prompt, and without answering the prompt fully, a 6 is a reasonable score to give J.
U. Essay #3: U starts off with many grammatical errors such as "it's" instead of "its" and actually using "+" instead of "and". The tenses don't always match up either, and his can be seen throughout the entire essay and effects the flow of the essay a bit. According to the AP grader, Things Fall Apart is a great example to use, if used correctly, which U did not. (The title was not underlined also.) U states, "the main goal in the novel is to "prevent things from falling apart." and has a central question as "does anything ever stay the same?" which don't connect very well. U's body paragraphs were incredibly vague and did not include specific examples to support any of the question stated in the introduction. The essay is disorganized, with a total of 2 paragraphs; the first being the introduction and the second being one example and a conclusion clumped together. U obviously didn't have enough examples and did not think about the depth of the novel. instead of just the surface story. Even thought the 'conclusion' does answer his/her central question in the end by stating "things do change + never stay the same.", however there isn't enough evidence. U received a 3. The only thing that saved U from receiving a 1 or 2 might have been having a statement that answered a central question.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteKathy,
ReplyDeleteThe lesson learned from these response essays is to always make sure you answer the question. This is not just an AP Lit peeve, but is an universal requirement for righting essays. However, this simple task seems to bite many of us AP Lit-ers, as we see in student U and J. My only critique would be that you did not provide as many direct quotes/examples from Studnet N's essay, as the other two. Your ability to analyze each student's work is pretty spot-on making an all together great post.
Hi Kathy,
ReplyDeleteGreat post. You analyzed the responses thoroughly, and gave good insights into the students' mistakes.
Though you used some direct quotations, more would be better. Direct quotations add credence to your claims, and imply a higher level of thoughtfulness.
Though you did well in providing the scores the AP Graders gave, I think you should form your own conclusions before listing the official number. I suspect, based on your criticism, you wouldn't have awarded "N" an eight. It makes the assignment more challenging to settle on a number first, but I think it's a good way to get the most learning out of the assignment.