Sunday, December 8, 2013

Closed Reading Sunday, December 8th

Miley Cyrus Has a Problem


Movie stars are often criticized for the actions they take to becoming famous and getting the attention of the media. It wasn't surprising to find the article Miley Cyrus Has a Problem in CNN's opinion section. The article's author, Dean Obeidallah, boldly uses diction, syntax, and details to show his disapproval of Miley Cyrus's actions to gain attention. 

It is obvious that Obeidallah is not a fan of Miley, and this can be seen through his bold use of diction. The first thing readers process from Obeidallah is that Miley is an 'addict'. Obeidallah then goes to allude fame to being a 'drug', the drug that Miley is addicted to. This creates a much bigger impact on readers than just saying that she wants fame because the author has now connected Miley to a mental problem. Miley is also accused of "manipulating the media" giving readers the idea that Miley has is sly and can't be trusted. On top of that, Obeidallah believes that Miley will continue to do more 'outrageous antics' to keep the media interested. Antics is referred to as a prank (dictionary.com) which highlights Obeidallah's earlier argument that Miley can't be trusted or taken seriously. When the author combines that with 'outrageous', we get the image of the stereotypical immature teenager pulling yet another prank and wasting their youth away. A few words usually don't make a big difference, but when put together intelligently like Obeidallah does in his article, disapproval and criticism can be seen leaking out of the pages. 

Not only is diction an important factor Obeidallah applies to his article, but he also uses syntax to emphasize his feelings towards Miley Cyrus. The very first sentence readers see is, "Miley Cyrus is an addict." Obeidallah uses a short sentence to add emphasis, like it is an indisputable statement. Readers also see short asides inserted within the article, separated by dashes like "And on some level, I -- along with others in the media -- am enabling her addiction." By doing this, it seems that the author is reaching out to his audience to make a connection with the readers, making it similar to a personal conversation face to face. 

Lastly, Obeidallah uses details to enhance his portrayal of Miley Cyrus. Obeidallah compares Miley to Sarah Palin and Donald Trump because they both became 'fame junkies' and became "nothing more than a walking punch line." Not only that, but he compares Lady Gaga and Miley Cyrus. While both have a quirky sense of style, Obeidallah is constantly explaining that what Lady Gaga does benefits people and Miley only harms people. He mentions that Miley Cyrus smoked marijuana publicly in Amsterdam (because it was legal) where as Lady Gaga goes on television to talk about her marijuana addiction experience and why people shouldn't go down that same road. Along with comparing Miley to Lady Gaga, Obeidallah goes on to praising Lady Gaga for her involvement in making a more positive world like supporting the "don't ask, don't tell policy." This set up the possible positive image that Miley could have been, but she chose to give society a negative image and message. Obeidallah specifically uses these examples to show his disrespect and disapproval to Miley Cyrus. 

Obeidallah's disapproval of Miley Cryus is obvious when he uses certain words to connect Miley to negative ideas while changing sentence structures to connect with the readers to portray his message better. On top of that, Obeidallah compares Miley to many other public figures, both like and not like herself, to show the disapproving qualities she possesses. Just through diction, syntax and details, Obeidallah has provided great evidence to readers of his disapproval of Miley Cyrus. 

3 comments:

  1. Hi Kathy,

    Wow, awesome job with pointing out how the author used DIDLS to show his negative opinion of Miley Cyrus. You definitely provided ample and relevant examples to prove your points. I especially liked how you pointed out how the author focused specifically on comparing Miley to other celebrity figures, highlighting her weaknesses with each copmarison. My only critique comes in your syntax paragraph. You used nice examples, but there could be more. Were there any other short sentences that showed forcefulness in the author's opinion? I'm also not too sure how the asides reached out to the audience -- because it created a more informal tone? On the whole, you did a great job with tying in each aspect of DIDLS with the author's intended meaning. Also, nice introduction and conclusion! Great job, Kathy!

    ReplyDelete
  2. This was a really impressive post, and it's hard to find much wrong with it. You did an excellent job at using textual evidence to support your claims and you show how the author uses DIDLS really well. Were than any examples of detail outside of the extended Lady Gaga comparison that the author used to portray Miley in a negative light? You touch briefly on the comparisons to Sarah Palin and Donald Trump. Was there more detail there? In other places?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Kathy,
    Really well done! You used excellent examples as well as an excellent amount of examples to support your statement that the author used diction, syntax, and details to prove his point. Your catch that the author was trying to relate himself to the audience was clever -- I don't think I would've see that.

    ReplyDelete