Sunday, December 15, 2013

Open Prompt (I) December 15th

AP English Literature and Composition 2008 Essay

Prompt: Function of a Foil

Essay #1: The student starts off with a very strong introduction, using Joy Luck Club by Amy Tan as the example to the prompt. She explains right away that Huang Tai Tai is the foil to Lindo Jong and explain that the characteristics of Huang Tai Tai accentuate the characteristics of Lindo Jong and emphasize their differences. This introduction shows that the student knows what a foil is and it's purpose, making it a great way to start off the essay. However, the body of the essay seems to contain too much summary and not enough information about Huang Tai Tai. All the information is aimed at Lindo Jong, explaining what kind of personality she has, and only giving up a little bit of information about Huang Tai Tai. The overall essay seems to contain the evidence needed to convince the reader somewhat that Huang is the foil to Lindo. The student ends the body paragraph with "She learned to respect herself and therefore illustrated the themes and meaning of the book." which is a little far from the original prompt: the function of a foil. Although the student does come back in the conclusion to wrap everything up, I don't agree with this student receiving a score of 8. The reader quotes that  “Huang was able to brainwash Lindo into thinking she had a good life . . . , and
that she owed everything she had to Huang.” was a good explanation to why Lindo was a foil to Huang, but that is only 1 example, the rest of the essay seemed to summarize the story to much.

Essay #2: This student's essay was not extremely clear in the beginning who Celia's foil is (from The Color Purple, no author given). The entire essay seems almost like a summary of the novel, focusing on Celia's struggles to becoming independent from the men in her life. To readers, it almost seemed that Shug was Celia's foil as the reader had also noted, but it turns out Celia's father is actually her foil when she states "Although Celia's father makes a brief appearance at the start of the novel, he attempts to affect Celia's life, setting as a foil, he represents every characteristic that Celia learns not to be." It isn't until this sentence is it clear to readers why Celia's father could serve as the foil. The essay does not effectively show that the student understood what a foil is and goes into too much detail such as Celia sinking karaoke at a bar and making special jeans to fit everyone's needs. The essay's message would have been better conveyed had the student just stuck to explaining why Celia was trying to be different from her father and not even included Shug, which confused readers. The student receives a score of 6, which is quite reasonable. The student's vocabulary is diverse and there aren't major grammatical errors. The main issue is introducing readers to another potential foil to Celia and not explaining who exactly the foil is at the beginning, which ends up confusing the readers later on.

Essay 3: This student starts off by stating that "Baba is a foil to Hassan", however, that sentence is followed by "He emphasizes good qualities in Hassan" which does little to prove to the readers that the student understood the meaning of a foil. The student does little to explain what characteristics of Baba that emphasize Hassan's good qualities. The student seemed to actually explain the similarities between Baba and Hassan, how they are both dishonest at times and how they are both loyal. The only contrast seen between the two characters is the description of Baba being 'extravagant' while Hassan was humble. The conclusion of the essay strays very far from the initial prompt and ends with explaining the 'meaning' of The Kite Runner (and does not include an author) as loyalty and friendship. The student's concluding sentence states that "Baba's foil to Hassan helps show this [loyalty and friendship] throughout the novel." which gives the impression to readers that the student did not quite understand what a foil is. The entire essay is a bit too 'simplistic' (as the reader had also noted) and contained incorrect grammar, overly simple sentence structures for an AP student (such as "Hassan is just like this.") and wandering ideas. The student never fully explains why Baba is a foil to Hassan. The explanations are thin and contain few details. The reader gave a score of 4 which accurately represents the student's lack of focus and knowledge on this topic. 

3 comments:

  1. Hi Kathy,

    Great job with covering the key points in the Open Prompt rubric -- plot summary vs. analysis, effective composition, and amount of support. You did a great job with hitting on exact problem in each student response. Well, I just chose the same prompt, and it seems as though, besides the first response, we are mostly in agreement. I actually thought that the sentence, "She learned to respect herself and therefore illustrated the themes and meaning of the book" showed well how Huang as a foil to Lindo contributed to the meaning of the book. To me the student was saying that through Huang, Lindo learned to respect herself, which was the main theme of The Joy Luck Club. But that's just my interpretation. The only other thing I'd say is that you could mention incorporate more analysis of how the students looked at DIDLS in each novel to answer the magic AP Lit questions: "How does the author use literary techniques to create meaning?" Overall, awesome job!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Like Debra, you did an excellent job at analyzing the essays on your own and I thought all the textual evidence you used to support your analysis was excellent. I also really liked that you looked at what score the essay was given by the readers and compared their analysis to your own. What scores would you have given each of these essays? I think your scores would have been the same for the last two essays, but you said that you disagreed with the score given to the first essay. What would you have given it instead?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Kathy,
    Nicely written critiques! I think these are the longest but most thorough open prompt essays I've read. You included textual evidence from the entirety of the students' essays, rather than touching upon just the beginning or just the end. Like Kevin, I'd like to know what score you would give the students since it'd give me more insight into how you really felt the essays were written.

    ReplyDelete