AP ENGLISH LITERATURE AND COMPOSITION 2009 ESSAY
Prompt: A Symbol (I think that is the only prompt instructions I get. I'm not sure if there is an actual prompt question for this unfortunately.)
Literature often contains many symbols to represent the many feelings and ideas essential to giving readers a clear message. One of the most famous examples of uses of symbolism is William Golding's Lord of the Flies. Golding's novel puts great emphasis on the importance of the conch shell to show character and event progression, and show themes in the novel.
The characters in Lord of the Flies are hugely impacted by the conch shell. The conch shell represents civilization and order, and is the only thing keeping some of the kids 'civilized' when they are dumped on an island from a plane crash. Piggy and Ralph are the first to find it, and Ralph blows into it to try and attract all the other kids on the plane. The conch shell got everyone assembled, and is seen as special, and valuable, like a crown. Seeing that Ralph is the only one who can blow it, the others automatically give him leadership and power. Ralph, wanting to keep everyone civilized, used the conch to devise a form of government to keep everyone civilized. Anyone holding the conch had the right to speak. Even the antagonist, Jack, had a bit of respect for the conch because he too treated it with care and respected its powers in the beginning. However, Jack breaks off from the group along with a few of his followers and turns into savages due to the lack of rules and order like one given by the conch to represent the crown. This shows the theme of civilization verses savagery. Jack's group actually go on to killing Piggy and the conch all together, killing the last hope for civilization and results in everyone loosing their civility and attacks Ralph. When the conch broke, Jack proclaimed himself to be the new 'chief', as there is no form of power, order, or civilization anymore.
Not only did the conch shell show how characters in Golding's novel progressed, it also showed event progression. Readers know that a conch shell is very beautiful, and it represents civilization because those who valued it with a monetary system saw it's value. The beginning of the novel starts with all the people, even Jack, being civilized, innocent, children. The conch was keeping things in order and the form of government was civilized, almost democratic. However, the conch, as pointed out by Piggy, is very delicate and if handled wrong, will shatter. This was a foreshadow to what will happen to the children if and when the conch broke. As the story progressed, the deterioration of civilization is shown as the once pure conch is tainted by the savage presence from the children, representing the loss of innocence of the children. Once the conch does break, the foreshadow became true as everyone left turns to attack Ralph, making it evident that all civilization is lost within the group.
The conch shell was made to represent civilization, power, and peace. Golding uses the conch to show how characters change and morph through out the story with the influence of the conch, along with using the conch to keep the events in the novel going while creating a turn of events. The conch is a symbol that shaped the entire story, both showing important themes while creating a world influenced around the conch.
Kathy,
ReplyDeleteGreat job with this essay. I like how you pulled in another text outside from those we were reading in class, and I was impressed by the strong understanding that you demonstrated. Also, is The Lord of The Flies supposed to be allegorical? Just from reading, I got that feeling but I have never read it, so I was just curious. Anyways, if it is, I think that might even be a good detail to add in as you describe the themes, even if it just demonstrates how much of an AP Lit prodigy you are. I felt like your details were relevant and your argument was pretty well-organized. But your connections to the central meaning were just a bit unclear for me. I feel like you might have been saying that man's natural state is anarchy and chaos without any order (as represented by the conch). It might help to actually just place in a theme statement in your thesis next time, so you can refer back to it throughout your argument, as opposed to elaborating on the symbol and trying to add in the theme. Also, I felt like you included a variety of details, but did not really explain them in the end. For example, I can see how the foreshadowing is relevant in your discussion, but how does that influence the overall effect of the story? Overall, great job!
Hi Kathy,
ReplyDeleteImpressive work! I loved how you incorporated insightful analysis throughout your essay. I wasn't able to find any big chunks comprised solely of summary, which was often a problem that many of the example students had in the essays we critiqued last semester. One area that I think may require a little elaboration or clarity would be your last body paragraph. You mentioned that the conch shows "event progression" which at first left me a little confused as to what you were trying to say in that third paragraph. After a couple more read throughs, I think I grasp your point, but a re-wording of that first topic sentence would increase the effectiveness of the evidence you're providing there, from a reader's perspective. Your conclusion is particularly satisfying, in that it briefly touches on all of your main points while restating your thesis. Clearly you aren't new to this stuff. Great job!
Eddie