Friday, February 14, 2014

Response to Course Material February 16th

Happy Single Awareness Day everyone! I'm not sure if I'll have access to internet while I'm away, so this this is probably the first and last time I do my blog at least 1 day before it's due!

So, after too many snow days and a controversial 'Be the Change!' day, we finally got to read Rosencranz and Guildenstern are Dead. I remember opening the book and reading right off the bat, "Two Elizabethans passing the time in a place without any visible character." Huh, so what does "without any visible character" mean? No setting? I tried so hard to imagine such a place, but that would have been quite impossible. I later came to the conclusion that maybe Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are in 'nothing'. I kind of applied it to the same concept as learning about the Big Bang theory. The universe started out as nothing right? So I kind of imaged the setting as the same kind of nothing, which is still hard for me to wrap my head around, but at least it's somewhere to start. But as I kept going, the coin game between Rosencrantz and Guildenstern became quite suspicious too. So basically, just this very beginning has thrown all my knowledge of math and science right out the window. By the end of the book, I was utterly confused. At first, I was very sad that both Rosencrantz and Guildenstern were dead, and hated Hamlet for a bit, but then wondered if they were really dead. After all, they were only sucked into the story right? But this leads to all the discussions we've been having lately, asking whether or not these two could be classified into the three categories: people, actors, or characters. My class seems to have come up with a conclusion, but I'm still wavering.

The movie, though, seemed to make a little more sense with there being a setting, first of all and being able to see the relationship between Ros and Guil. I personally thought the book made their relationship sound a bit strained and less familiar, whereas the movie seemed to portray them as friends. There was a part in the movie, though, that really confused me. When Ros invented this amazing pot stirring contraption and Guil broke it to get access to the hot water, what was Guild doing? He poured it into a shallow bowl and started to almost wash his hands, but looked like he was only playing with the water instead. You guys know what I'm talking about? It almost seemed...pointless. Does anyone else see meaning to that? Or maybe I'm over thinking it.

This play is so abstract that I'm not even sure what the point to the story is. From the handout we annotated, it almost seemed to say that Stoppard was mocking Shakespeare, but I don't see that at all. It was, after all, not the greatest review of this play (at least in my opinion). He didn't mention anything about Stoppard breaking the 4th wall, and by his definition of Theater of the Absurd, even something like All Quite On the Western Front could be a theater of the absurd idea. It does, after all, take place in WWI, the main character goes off to fight a war, and sees soldiers flinging themselves at bullets because of the loyalty to their country that Paul had long ago forgotten. It really was kind of 'pointless', seeing Paul live his days with few meaning, few hopes to live and having a life afterwords. He does die in the end (sorry for the spoiler) and nothing seems to have been accomplished throughout the novel. The war still goes on even when Paul dies. For anyone else who's read this particular book, do you think Johnston might have been a little vague on his definition of Theater of the Absurd?

Enough with Ros and Guil. I want to know what everyone thought of the AP essay practice we did in the lab, yeah the super stressful thing that nobody but Max finished. For me, I spent most of my time trying to make a really good prompt, and ended up with about 20 minutes to actually write. The prompt I ended up picking was quite short, and quite vague. We learned to make sure to answer every part of the prompt in our intro, but there was so little to answer that my intro was only 2 sentences long. I won't say that is why my essay sucked, but it did make it very difficult to elaborate on my intro when the prompt asked very little to begin with. I almost think the quality of the essay first comes from the quality of the prompt being asked. But another issue I had was not reading enough books. To be honest, I've never read The Great Gatsby, The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, The Grapes of Wrath, or Brave New World and sometimes I find it hard to answer a prompt using something other than Hamlet. I'm not sure if it's just me, but does anyone else feel under-prepared for this exam coming up in...3 months?!

3 comments:

  1. Kathy,
    Happy belated singles awareness day to you as well. I'd never thought about the setting-less setting of the R&G the way you had, about it being like the nebulous nothing before the creation of the universe, where literally nothing existed (which is a damn hard concept to wrap your head around). With this viewpoint I'm starting to see how really sheer and bleak the existences of R & G really are: trapped in a world of no logic, no form, no anything, their lives predetermined for them by a ruthless Stoppard who sends them off to die (he didn't necessarily have to; he is a writer after all, not bound by Shakespeare, who's dead and can't send him scathing fan mail anymore); Lord, I kind of feel bad for those two. To be one-dimensional, lost, confused, it kind of reminds me of how real people feel sometimes. About that scene in the film, it confused me just as much as it confused you, because why would you arbitrarily derp around with boiling water in a shallow dish; it makes no sense. I thought about it briefly, and the silliness of that situation might be Guildenstern trying to prove to himself that he has free will, because he can do stupid, random things with his surroundings that would not necessarily be dictated by a rational higher power. But, as we see, Stoppard does not think in normal rational terms, so even though Guildenstern thinks he has free will because he splashes around with boiling water, he really doesn't, because Stoppard told him to do so in the script. Or maybe it was ad-libbed; I'm not gonna consider that because the situation would become too confusing. That's my take on things, though. You and I had similar situations with the lab assignment; I couldn't come up with any prompt ideas so I essentially had no time to write anything coherent. With other APs, I found a formula or a groove of sorts that I could sit in and work with; AP Lit is a lot more subjective. There is a formula, but it's no longer "list the evidence here and write a conclusion" like it was in APUSH. I think I'm gonna have a bad time during this AP exam if I don't learn how to just vomit my ideas onto a page and call it good, though I'm not worried for some reason. Maybe I should be worried.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Kathy!

    I really like the connections you drew between the "void" (as I envision it) that R and G are trapped in and the nothingness that we imagine came before the Big Bang. I didn't even think about it that way! But I suppose that, for them, getting "summoned" to perform in Hamlet is kind of like a Big Bang, right? They don't really have an existence until that happens. And I took the coin part as establishing the lack of a "horizon of significance" (or whatever it was called in that essay we read). If a coin can land heads that many times, then it's safe to assume the rules we live by don't apply in the play.

    I don't think it's a huge problem that you haven't read some of the more commonly used books. There are quite a few that I haven't read either, but I feel pretty safe responding to the prompts so far. From what I've seen, Hamlet can be used to respond to just about anything. I think that by the end of the year, we'll have a pretty solid collection of books to reference in open prompts.

    That being said, I'm definitely pretty iffy about the whole open prompt thing. I've never been good at timed essays, and these are no different. I can write a thesis, but it takes me a really long time and I never feel comfortable with the essay I end up with. I definitely feel a little nervous about the test, but I have faith that things will get easier as we get more practice.

    Nice work! I really enjoyed this post.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Kathy,

    It's obvious that you've stayed pretty engaged this past month. It seems that you and I had pretty similar thought processes regarding R & G in that it took me significantly longer than the rest of the class to reach an interpretation of the novel that I felt confident in. It's nice to know I wasn't the only one. Awesome connection to All Quiet On The Western Front. I've seen the old movie, but I've never read the book. From my viewing of it on screen, I never would've considered the absurdist elements in it, so thanks for the interesting new perspective. Regarding your reflection on the in-class essay structure practice, I think I can pretty safely say that most of us are in the same boat with that--not including Max, perhaps. Since it's a new concept for us I think all we need is to develop a time-sensitive formula that will encourage us to abandon some of our perfectionist habits and focus more on the actual task at hand. The other day Holmes suggested that I emphasize certain aspects of DIDLS and STIFS more so than others, focusing more heavily on those that have the greatest impact on the expression of meaning. (i.e. details versus syntax) Have no fear, I'm sure all AP students have felt the pressure during these few months before the exam. It doesn't necessarily mean we're under-prepared. Anyway, wonderful reflection. Very thoughtful.

    ReplyDelete