By now I probably should have learned not to put off my blogs
until the last day to do them, especially when my electricity and Wi-Fi are at
the risk of being obliterated by the tree next door, so this may just be the
fastest, and shortest blog I write yet. We'll see.
So, for the main topic? You guessed it, Hamlet. After finishing the play
Hamlet, and watching 4 or 5 different versions of this play, I've come
to realize how incredibly wrong I was when I was writing the Tiv tribe interpretation
forum about the different ways to interpret Hamlet (or should I say the lack of ways
one can interpret Hamlet?). Each
version of the play had a little bit of a different interpretation of
Shakespeare's same words. Earlier in the blog post, I had argued that there
could only ever be 1 correct interpretation of Hamlet. Thinking back on it, I realized that they all seemed to
tell a very similar message, have similar themes etc. I noticed that the
Branaugh version of Hamlet
made Hamlet a bit more aggressive than I thought he was in the original play whereas
the Hawke version (the modern version) made Hamlet seem more 'in love' with
Ophelia, but the themes messages where all still there. I've come to realize
that all these interpretations are exactly what we see when we see our favorite
teen books coming out in movies. Each person, movie producer, reader etc. has
their own interpretation but they all come out with a similar story.
Speaking of interpretation, the
Ophelia poem for our forum post was also all about interpretations. The author
seemed to portray Ophelia in almost an angelic light which some readers
disagreed with when reading Hamlet. I
had read Mary E's post for reviewing and she made a great point about Hamlet
falling from grace (kind of like Lucifer) and becoming the devil, defying God's
orders etc. I think that's a great point. It's kind of amazing how many books,
even today, are still linked to religion. We all know the book City of Bones right? Believe it or not,
I've found quite a few religious references, for example, did you know that
Valentine represents Satan? He does create The Circle and Morgenstern actually
means 'morning star'. I think you can figure the rest out from there. So where
do I get all these crazy ideas from? Well, it's called reading How to Read Literature Like a Professor.
When in doubt, it's from Shakespeare...or the Bible right?
What did everyone think of the NPR story about Hamlet being performed in prison? It really surprised me how much I enjoyed listening to that. Before I listened to it, I thought 'oh jeez, prisoners performing Hamlet? Someone's going to die'. Instead, I learned that prisoners are just normal people like you and me. We all take a step in the wrong direction sometimes, and that's exactly what happened to these prisoners. The only difference between the prisoners and I is that I've made fewer wrong decision. To see/hear prisoners comparing their lives with Hamlet was such an abstract idea, but now I understand why this was a step in the right direction for these actors. I think this story really made a big impact on my life, and how I will act in the future. I was raised to always stay away from the really sketchy looking people, but really, it's what's on the inside that counts. To be honest, the big guy calling everyone minnows reminded me of a child saying "I'm going to be king when I grow up and you will all have to be my servants!" The image these prisoners have really don't reflect what is going on inside them, and Hamlet was what brought them all together. An hour of this NPR recording has really altered my view on people, and I will definitely take this story into account as I move on in life.
Sorry I may have some really weird breaks in here due to my Wi-Fi and electricity problems. I'll make sure to edit this before anyone reviews this!
Hi Kathy,
ReplyDeleteGreat job tying in outside material with your post (although I have never read City of Bones, so I can't comment on that). It's a hard debate whether there are multiple correct interpretations or only one. To me, the correct interpretation is the one Shakespeare originally intended, but since we'll never truly know what is, we have multiple interpretations. It's like music: there are many interpretations, but the goal of each is to follow what the composer originally had intended. As for your comment on religion, I completely agree with you! Religion definitely still permeates many modern novels. I think it's because of how old and widespread religion is -- it is found all over the world, an innate part of many cultures. I'm glad the NPR recording had such a big impact on your life. I'm sure many other people had the same reaction as you when initially hearing that prisoners were playing Hamlet -- it's amazing how a simple idea can change so many people's perspectives on life. This was a great post, Kathy! It was full of your thoughts and opinions -- it was captivating!
And you were worried about these being short...
ReplyDeleteThis was a very thorough look back on what we did in class. Excellent work! What do you think had lead you to believe that there could only be one correct interpretation of a work previously? I thought it was cool that seeing various interpretations of something has changed your opinion on interpretations altogether. Did the change affect your analysis of Hamlet later? And did the exposure to other interpretations change your own individual interpretation?
this*
DeleteKathy,
ReplyDeleteLike I said to Debra, it would be nice to hear what you liked or disliked specifically with each film. Your comment on how religion is seen in modern texts as much as old is very true. For me, Lord of the Rings is the perfect example of this and I've never read City of Bones so I can't really comment on that! Good job of bringing outside sources to prove your point, though. Personally, I disagree with you in that prisoners are "normal people" like you and me. I think that's a huge generalization because these few prisoners who decided to play Hamlet are a small, small portion of the prison population and I think if we were to meet the rest of them, you wouldn't think they were like us. All in all, good insight though. It's refreshing to read a different perspective than my own!