Sunday, February 9, 2014

Open Prompt (Part II) February 9th

2008 AP English and Literature

Prompt:  In a literary work, a minor character, often known as a foil, possesses traits that emphasize, by contrast or comparison, the distinctive characteristics and qualities of the main character. For example, the ideas or behavior of a minor character might be used to highlight the weaknesses or strengths of the main character. Choose a novel or play in which a minor character serves as a foil for the main character. Then write an essay in which you analyze how the relation between the minor character and the major character illuminates the meaning of the work.

George and Lennie from Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck serve as foils to each other. While the friendship between the two characters are extremely close, their personality and physical traits contrast each other, emphasizing their differences. Steinbeck uses these differences to emphasize themes and motifs throughout the novel.

Right off the bat, Steinbeck emphasizes the differences between George and Lennie. George is physically, thin, and small. While George is not that small compared to the average man, Lennie is such a large character, a "shapeless man" that it emphasizes  just how small and thin George looks in comparison. This is quite ironic because George and many others used to pick on Lennie despite his enormous strength and size. Because of his big size, Lennie is pretty slow, which only emphasizes George's quickness. However, Lennie is also slow, mentally while George is intelligent and cunning.

Not only do their physical traits contrast each other, their personalities also differ greatly. George is a realist, having learned the harshness of life, he knows how hard life is. Steinbeck, on the other hand, makes Lennie a static character, incapable of growing. Lennie still lives in the dream of owning a farm with bunnies. He loves soft and fluffy things, and cannot see the evils of the world. The idea of the American dream had not been lost to Lennie. This almost creates a father and son relationship between George and Lennie. George, having experiences and absorbed the evils of the world, tries had to protect Lennie, the innocent little son. He constantly takes care of Lennie, making sure he doesn't get into trouble while Lennie likes to dream about living on a farm with his 'father' and taking care of bunnies. This comparison further contrasts the personalities of the two characters even though.

Steinbeck uses the contrasting characteristics between Lennie and George, both physically, and mentally, to emphasize certain motifs and themes in his novel. While George is short, and thin, Lennie is large, and heavy. Their personalities are ironic considering their physical appearances though. George on the other hand, is cunning and intelligent while Lennie is mentally slow and often bullied because of his innocence. These contrasting characteristics create the perfect foil to each other, making their differences emphasize the significance of each other's differences.


3 comments:

  1. Hi Kathy!

    I like this post a lot. I've never read this book, but it seems like you did a good job of proving that they are foils. However, it doesn't seem like you went very far past that. You discussed themes and motifs in your thesis paragraph, but didn't really address them past that. The prompt also said to discuss how the contrast between characters "illuminates the meaning of the work as a whole," and I really didn't see any of that either. You might want to add a third paragraph addressing meaning if you go back and edit this.

    Aside from missing some parts of the prompt, I think this is formatted well. I like the way you organized it around the different types of characteristics. There were a few awkward sentences, like the last one of the third paragraph which really didn't make sense. It also seems like you're a little comma-happy sometimes. For example, one of your sentences talks about how " while George is short, and thin, Lennie is large, and heavy." There shouldn't be commas after "short" or "thin." You would only need those if you had been listing other characteristics beforehand. This happened in quite a few places, but other than that I think your writing is technically sound.

    Overall, good job! I really enjoyed reading this.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Kathy,

    Great job here! This prompt seems to be a particularly popular one. I've found myself reviewing responses to it a number of of times. Anyway, I noticed that your introductory paragraph could've benefited from a little more elaboration. You mentioned how the differences between Lenny and George emphasize themes and motifs in the novel, but which themes/motifs do they emphasize? I think introductions generally require that level of specificity. It's probably worth asking Ms. Holmes about, at least. Following that, you provided great evidence for the foil that makes it clear that you've thoroughly read the piece. However, you don't seem to comment on how this strong foil relationship affects the meaning of the work as a whole. As Emma said, I think the best revision you could make here would be to address the second part of the prompt more directly. Aside from that, though, this piece doesn't seem to be lacking any essential elements, so kudos! Seems like you've got a pretty good handle on this whole "open prompt" thing.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Emma and Eddie: really excellent analytical commentary on this essay--you have identified the issues that need work accurately and specifically.

    ReplyDelete