Sunday, March 9, 2014

Open Prompt (Part II) March 9th

Prompt: In many works of literature, past events can affect, positively or negatively, the present activities, attitudes, or values of a character. Choose a novel or play in which a character must contend with some aspect of the past, either personal or societal. Then write an essay in which you show how the character’s relationship to the past contributes to the meaning of the work as a whole.

Mary Shelly's Frankenstein narrates the story of a monster created by Victor Frankenstein. Frankenstein's monster was originally created due to Frankenstein's own curiosity. However, The Monster's appearance is so frightening that Frankenstein abandons his own creation. Unfortunately, society also mistreats The Monster due to prejudice based on his outer appearance. The mistreatment that The Monster faces in the past lead him to become bitter and vengeful. Shelly contrasts the negative effects of the past on The Monster to his once gentle and kind nature to emphasize the true nature of human beings.

Victor Frankenstein, a genius scientist and alchemist, creates a monster out of dead body parts sewn together and a spark of electricity. The Monster is then born into the world only to be rejected by his own 'father' due to his horrendous appearance. The unrequited love causes The Monster to realize his own hideous appearance. The Monster tries and tries again to get the attention of Victor only to be resented and lied to. These very first events causes the inherently good natured, and kind Monster to be fill with anger, hurt, and vengence. The lack of love for The Monster during the very early stages of his life teaches The Monster to become hateful and murderous.

Not only did Victor, The Monster's own creator, reject him, but society as a whole rejected him based of previous prejudice. The Monster is a good hearted person at the beginning of the novel; he saves a girl from drowning and anonymously helps a family get through a tough winter. However, society, much like Victor, decides to harm The Monster solely based on his frightening appearance and his large stature which resembles a monster. After being shot at and rejected by the very family he learned to love, The Monster realizes that no one will be willing to accept him; not society and not even his own creator. All of the disgust and prejudice directed towards The Monster early on in his life makes him become vengeful, killing the dearest people to Victor, and therefore a murderer.

A once kind hearted and innocent creation is turned into a monster from the loveless and prejudice world he lives in. Shelly uses these mistreatment to justify the belief that humans, like The Monster, are born naturally good but become cruel from the effects of society as a whole. The kind hearted Monster represents the kind nature of human beings at the beginning of their life journey, and the final vengeful product of The Monster shows the effects society has on humans, and how the past can define the person one is today.

3 comments:

  1. Kathy,
    Your essay is strong, but there are a few things that you need to add in order to receive a 9. All your arguments are well articulated; however the AP exam requires us to analyze different aspects of DIDLS. Be sure to discuss literary techniques other than details to fuel your argument. You could discuss the imagery used to describe The Monster, the diction that Victor used to show how strongly he loathed The Monster, or the language and devices used to communicate different messages that contributed to the meaning of the work as a whole. Try prewriting to fully shape your argument. It may feel time consuming, but once you have an idea of what you will say, the words flow quickly to make up for that time. Your claims were great, so just back them up with different types of DIDLS and this essay will be solid.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Kathy,
    All your facts are spot on here and I think your analysis is great. You make sure to keep reminding the reader that The Monster undergoes a significant shift in disposition from kind to murderous. I see what Mariah is saying that including DIDLS will help you as far as AP SCORE goes. Instead of dedicating the whole essay to listing examples of how The Monster was wronged in the past, give the author more credit and describe how she presented the conflict of past and present in the novrl.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Kathy,
    I appreciate your use a book outside of AP Lit. However, this essay is a little lean. You make good use of plot as evidence for your claim, but what other things could you draw from Frankenstein to support your argument? Other, specific plot details? DIDLS? I'm just afraid that an AP Grader would ding you falling into plot summary a little too much.

    ReplyDelete