Sunday, March 16, 2014

Response to Course Material March 16th

Ok good news? About 9 more weeks of school!!! That means 9 more dreaded Mondays!! (Not counting Spring Break, I'm too lazy to calculate that in)

The bad news? 7 weeks until APs....

So the last time I wrote a Response to Course Material blog was..February 16th, which means it has been exactly 1 month, and a lot has happened. We came back from President's day weekend and practiced multiple choice for the AP while Holmes took us aside to talk to us about our essays. We wrote that essay a while ago, so most of us don't even remember what happened that day. But Holmes gave some good tips earlier but we may not have taken them all into account since she scolded us for the Open Prompts she read on our blogs. But having spoken to Holmes individually really helped me understand what the goal to the essay is. I was pretty happy to have received a 7 on the closed prompt we wrote in class (then edited and shared with Holmes) but then I realized that a 7 with 2 days to revise and less pressure probably equates to a 4 on the actual AP, so I guess I have a lot more work to do. It makes me feel like a kid again, learning how to ride a bike with training wheels on. After that has been accomplished, the hard part is taking the training wheels off. Yikes. 

Sadly we said our goodbyes to Ros and Guil. It seemed to me that the more discussions we had, the more confusing the book got. I wasn't in lit on Thursday and Friday, so I have a different theme statement than the unanimous ones from the previous hours and the one from my own how. I ended up with the idea that Stoppard wanted the audience to know that they are not in a play, and therefore should take control of their own boats. I was glad to have realized that others wrote a similar theme statement, but some argued that Stoppard thought that fate does exist and even you can't do anything about it. Funny how even in the same class, having the same discussions, we come up with polar opposite ideas. In the beginning of the year with The American Dream, we all seemed to agree on one idea and that was it. There was little argument to it. I remember how we used to wrack our brains trying to think of a theme for The American Dream and get a good understanding of the book, but looking back on it, we were either oblivious to details or we have just gotten much better at understand them.

Finally we moved on to Ceremony, at least for a short while. The presentations we read/watched in class proved to be useful. They allowed me to experience the culture and beliefs of the Native Americans. However, I still find Ceremony very hard to understand. What gets me the most are the movement of time. I can't tell if a certain part that I'm reading is happening before, right after, or way past that unless I've read the section about 3 times. But the question I was dying to know while I was reading was, what happens if someone in AP Lit happens to be Japanese? I noticed at the beginning of the book, there were some pretty racist remarks towards the Japanese, and having relatives who have fought against the Japanese, even I felt that it was a bit too much. Wouldn't you be offended if you went to study abroad in England and you were required to read a novel that spoke ill of the American?

Recently we've been working a lot on placing literature in a certain lens. Apparently 1st and 2nd hour have been doing a great job and have been coming upon many revelations, but 6th hour doesn't seem to be getting anywhere. Don't kill me Mrs. Holmes, but I think what is happening is that a lot of us don't quite understand what certain lenses mean and its purpose. I was also wondering if certain lenses can not pertain to certain books. In one of our discussions with The American Dream, I remember someone saying, "Let's not do that lens. I don't think it applies to this book", but going thorough the lenses again, I realize they can all be a way to view The American Dream, unless I'm missing one. But hopefully we get more time to go over these lenses, because I have a feeling these will become a big part of our class later.

4 comments:

  1. Kathy,
    First off, your rant is very accurate. I find doing homework the most difficult task to accomplish even though I’m most experienced at doing it, senioritis is real. Anyways I felt the same way about Ros and Guil, even during the final discussions I was still a bit confused. I just keep in mind that Stoppard’s play will not be my #1 choice to discuss on the AP exam, but even if I do end up using it we made a theme statement that I feel solid with regarding the difference between life and art. I think Ceremony was a fascinating novel. My favorite books to read are sci-fi/fantasy, so branching out to some Native American fiction was refreshing and I enjoyed it. I found the writing confusing, but it kept me reading until the end to figure out exactly what was happening. It takes time to fully understand everything the different ways of criticism work, just keep in mind that they are angles at which to look on a work. If you look at a person from the side versus from the back you get a completely different perception of them; the same goes for literature. Great job!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Kathy,
    I can totally relate to your training wheel analogy. Learning how to properly write an essay has been a challenge for me this year as well. It makes me question if anything I have learned about writing essays, up to this point, is valid information. Now, when you say the comments about the Japanese were "too much", do you mean that we should not read a book with such content in class? I am interested because being mixed-race, it was very interesting to listen to my classmates discuss if miscegenation was good or bad. Although I found some of their commentary ignorant or hurtful, I think there are benefits for reading material with touchy subject matter in a group of diverse people. For some it can be enlightening to see how far as a community we have come and learn to appreciate each other more as people. However, it can also make for a very uncomfortable hour. I also wrote in my response that I am not very familiar with the lenses. However, it sounds like we will have to freshen up our knowledge on our own time. Great hearing your perspective on the class, Kathy!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Kathy,
    So, this post is special. You seem quite invested in conveying things that are separate from this class. Why? I don't want to be mean, but couldn't you make other places for more personal writing? I'm just not sure I can understand the motivation behind including something like that in a class assignment.
    In the Response to Course Material portion, you mention that the ill-speaking towards the Japanese was "too much." What do you mean? Did you interpret that as Silko's point of view, or the point of view of a character? Did you find the book racist as a whole? How would you rather Silko have touched on the very real anti-Japanese sentiment in post-WWII America?
    This is a good post Kathy, but, again, I think some other place would be more appropriate for your non-Lit related writing.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well there was a reason I told you not to read that portion if you didn't want to.I did state that it has nothing to do with lit, so I'm sorry if I wasted your time. I guess in that moment I just felt the need to rant and I meant to take it off before you guys read the post but I guess I forgot. I'll make sure to keep personal matters out of school in the future.

      Delete