Sunday, October 27, 2013

Response to Course Material Oct 27th

Wow time flies. It seems that it was only last week when we did our last 'Response to Course Material' blog. But in that short time, we covered Death of Salesman, analyzed some poetry, ate some crust-less pie, and tried to define tragedy.

In order to help us understand Death of a Salesman better, Ms. Holmes has us watch the movie first. And I must say, without the movie, I would have had a big issue following along with the text. The movie allowed me to see the visual effects the directors added into the movie to differentiate the past and the present. I did notice however, that while I was reading/watching Death of a Salesman, I made a few connections to The American Dream. Both of the plays talk about an American Dream, and both have 2 different dreams. Grandma symbolizes the old American Dream and Biff is the character chasing that old American Dream. He wants to work on the farms, and be free, not tied down in a suit and piles of papers. And Mommy and Daddy are constantly chasing the new American Dream, which coincidentally, Willy Loman was also chasing the new American Dream. I'm not sure if Holmes did this on purpose or not, but I could see little connection between the plays. (Ex: Mommy's short story about her wheat hat, and her need to conform to society/chairman of her woman's club vs Willy Loman's need to be well liked and accepted by society/fellow salesmen.) To be honest, I wouldn't have been able to connect these ideas together without the help of this class and the class discussions. I realized that Holmes gave us a much, much shorter discussion time for Death of a Salesman than The American Dream, probably because of the similar (but different) ideas in both. Or maybe the longer discussion on The American Dream was to help set up our brains and train them to think beyond just the words. But whatever you did Ms. Holmes, I now have a better understand of analyzing literature, so thanks you!

Along with those pieces, we also practiced some multiple choice and were given 3 handouts, Tragedy of a Common Man, Confusion and Tragedy, and Changing Definitions of Tragedy. This really gave me a different perspective of literature labeled as tragedies. Foster's paper argues why DOS would not be considered a tragedy and uses some pretty harsh language to prove his point, or rather, TRY to prove his point. I often found myself saying to Foster, "Dude. Times have changed! Where on Earth (with the exception of England) will you find some famous royal people?". Miller's argument in Tragedy of a Common Man made much more sense to me. The common man can represent a hero on the inside. It's not the status of the man that makes him a hero, therefore, allowing a common man to fall tragically too. So from now on, even when I'm reading chic-lit or something of the like, I'll be arguing with myself on whether or not one of the characters have made even a chic-lit a tragedy.

While annotating Death of a Salesman and The American Dream, it reminded me of taking a test. First you must read the question very carefully, then hunt down the answer. But, there are so many answers, sometimes even more than one correct answer. We sometimes even debate answers with our teachers because of what we believe. And sometimes with certain teachers, you can find the answer to question #5 in question #46, (vise versa) just like a book. Books will give you confusing things to ponder, and sometimes there is more than one correct answer. Sometimes while reading, we realize we found an answer way in the beginning of the book without realizing it. And at the end of the test/annotating the book, it makes you realize how much you'be learned or need to work on. I guess this will help with both my annotating and test taking when it comes time for that dreaded AP exam.

So we actually spend more time going through the poem Promises like Pie Crust than Death of a Salesman. Promises like Pie Crust is a poem written by Christina Rosetti. And once again, I must mention my failure to comprehend poetry at the level of an analysis. I didn't understand the connection with pie and promises. But after much discussion, I finally understood that pie crust crumbles (who knew?) just like promises. They are fragile and break, but it must be broken to get to the 'sweet stuff' on the inside (OK, I obviously don't eat pie, so thank you Max for bringing us your delicious crust-less pie). I always think the class discussion help me so much*. It gives me another perspective on the poem. Other wise, I would have sat there for god knows how long not knowing that pie crust crumbles.

It's funny how after every analysis of a piece we do, I always find a way for it to connect and affect my life whether it's Promises Like Pie Crust, Death of a Salesman or The American Dream. Ever since reading The American Dream, I've been checking myself to make sure I haven't become a Mommy or a Daddy. I've actually started using DIDLS instead of just reading books for pleasure, so all these hidden meanings come out of the story that wasn't there before. Now even my air-headed chic-lit characters turn into something a little darker. Um, thanks AP lit?

* (Some people will argue that I never talk through the discussions. And that's right, because taking the time to think of something to say is time away from the discussion to hear what others have to say. And trust me when I say this, but I think INCREDIBLY slow. So by the time I would have got something in my head ready to say, I would have missed 3 or 4 comments said. So that's enough of my lame personal excuse.)

4 comments:

  1. Oh, don't worry--we aren't done with our DOS discussions yet, not by any means! And yes, the texts are sequenced like that on purpose--see if you can figure out, when we read Hamlet, next, why it follows DOS. =)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great response, Kathy. It's interesting to see how other students feel about the course material. I noticed a lot of the parallels between Dream and Salesman as well, and it makes me wonder if the rest of our curriculum will relate to the American dream/experience in some way. Then again, our next reading is Hamlet, so maybe not, but I wouldn't be surprised if Holmes found a way. With regards to your opinion on the Tragedy readings, I have to respectfully disagree. I still think Foster knows what he's taking about! Sure he was a little overly critical, and maybe even condescending, but I agree that it doesn't make sense to call a piece of literature a tragedy if it doesn't fit the definition. Call me old-fashioned, but I don't think Salesman is actually tragic. I loved the way you compared annotating to test-taking. I hadn't looked at it that way before, so thanks for the new perspective!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Excellent post, Kathy. I thought I was cool-beans being mentioned by Ms. Holmes, but your post feels way more deserving of a mention than mine. The connections you draw between our classroom material are very thorough, and well communicated. That's something I'll have to strive for.
    However, I think you should make more connections with specific things outside of class. Your link between tragedy and chic-lit is great, but there should be more of them, and an example of a chic-lit novel would be fantastic. I suppose there's a balance to be drawn between in-class connections and extra-curricular connections, and I think your "scale" should tip more towards extra-curricular stuff.
    Outside of that, this is a really nice post. You've provided us with an excellent window into your mind.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Kathy, this was a well-written response to the course materials.

    Personally, I would prefer doing an in-class quick read to watching the film, because I was not able to completely comprehend what was going on in the film; the characters were not verbally coherent. Despite that, I agree that the class discussions on “Death of a Salesman” were very helpful for me, because I was able to notice things that I was not able to in my close reading. The 3 articles on the definition of a tragedy also gave me different perspectives of this play, and I still vacillate between “’Death of a Salesman’ is a tragedy” and “’Death of a Salesman’ is not a tragedy”
    I liked how you said that while Grandma manifests the old American Dream, Biff is trying to pursuit that. I have never realized that connection between the two plays.
    Overall, this was a thorough and entertaining response to course materials.

    ReplyDelete