Sunday, October 13, 2013

Closed Reading Sunday, October 13

'Fat letters' From Schools to Parents are Wrong


Schools used to be a social center for strictly learning, but now, according to Ruben Navarrette, the schools are unnecessarily controlling student diets and weights. Ruben is against policies of many states that take heights and weights to calculate BMIs and then sent to parents. Ruben's voice can be heard loud and clear with his use of diction, syntax, and language. 

Diction is such an important part to hearing Ruben's voice shine in his article. For example, "hocus-pocus" isn't a word you often read while browsing through CNN, but Ruben uses it to describe dietitians' methods of labeling students by their BMIs. Ruben doesn't use words like "method", instead, he chose "hocus-pocus" to bring on a tone of immaturity, unprofessional-ism, and an overall tone of disapproval. Not only that, but "Schools have been slapping labels on students..."  really gets the point across to readers that labeling students is harmful. Schools are not simple labeling students in Ruben's opinion, they're SLAPPING labels on students, making the action sound harmful and painful to students. Ruben made sure to carefully choose his words to create such disapproving tones throughout his article.

Not only is diction important, but Ruben's use of syntax helps readers feel his emotions. Throughout the article, short and or fragmented sentences can be found to emphasize ideas such as, "Fat letters.", "They had a point.", and "for mentally retarded." Just from a simple sentence, ("And what do students call these notes? "Fat letters.") readers can hear Ruben's emphasis on the name of the notes and it's importance. Ruben also uses a series of rhetorical questions to get readers to see the irony and hear his sarcasm.  ("Schools can't afford foreign language courses, sports programs or music classes. But they found funds for dieticians?") Lastly, Ruben uses the -ing form of verbs constantly to show it's presence forcefully. He mentions that schools "are receiving letters regarding something that really isn't a school's business" which shows how prevalent it is in people's lives at the moment and it's urgency. Just through syntax alone, readers can note Ruben's disapproving and critical tone. 

However, disapproving and critical aren't' the only tones heard throughout the article. I must compliment Ruben on his use of language. I'm not saying he chose to swear every other sentence; there wasn't a single swear word in the article. In fact, Ruben chose to use simple words and sentences casually to get his point across. While Ruben was being persuasive, his casual choice of words allowed readers to relate and understand him instead of just hear an argument. Furthermore, his use of the rhetoric as sarcasm allows the readers to sit back and laugh, making Ruben seem to be the better guy. He's not talking at you, digging around facts like a lawyer (no offense to anyone...), he's talking with you, and laughing with you too. He uses similar sentence structure for sentences, but changes up words for emphasis in his comparisons. "Many educators today might have a handle on math, science and reading. But they're flunking compassion, empathy, tact and sensitivity." Again, he almost sounds comedic, like you could add  'ba-dum tss" at the end. But we all know it's not funny, that Ruben is actually quite serious about the issue when he follows up these moments with a serious reality. 

Ruben uses a mix of diction, syntax and language to successfully portray his disapproval but also sincere plead for understanding of the current 'fat letters' issue. His mixture of serious and comedic moments allow the readers to get a feel for his character and tone in the article making readers feel compelled to side with this author. 

4 comments:

  1. Good stuff, Kathy! I like your article choice--Navarrette has a really strong voice here. You commented on how his diction, particularly his choice of the word "hocus-pocus", brought on a tone of immaturity. Did this make it harder for you to take the article seriously, or does it add to the aspect of humor that you mentioned in your conclusion? Personally, I think it makes him seem sort of ignorant, regardless of whether or not his heart is in the right place. Another thing I noticed was that you analyzed his word choice when making claims about his use of language. Holmes informed me that the term, as is it is included in DIDLS, refers to an author's usage of figurative language such metaphors, similes, etc. I made this same mistake on my last close reading post, so you are not alone! By the way, your emphasis on the syntactical elements of the piece was helpful to me, as I typically struggle with that sort of analysis. Your examples will help me to identify similar patterns in future texts, so thanks for that. All in all, a thoughtful analysis.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Good post, Kathy. You picked a strongly voiced article.
    I think next time you should start these posts off with a clear and consistent thesis. I don't think it's enough to say that "Reuben's voice can be heard loud and clear." What should be supporting paragraphs end up each having little min-theses, totaling to an inconsistent analysis. Ms. Holmes wants these to be in the form of a these-driven essay, so I think the closer to that, the better.
    However, you do effectively analyze the techniques you chose. You include many specific textual examples, which would serve well in a more thesis-y context.
    In your final paragraph, you write: "I must compliment Ruben on his use of language. I'm not saying he chose to swear every other sentence; there wasn't a single swear word in the article." I think you were trying to make a joke, but it feels out of place and distracts from your message. Next time, I would resist the temptation to insert little unrelating quips.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Kathy, this was a well-written close reading analysis.
    You chose an article with a strong voice, as indicated by the title itself. I also think that this an incorrect solution to America’s obesity crisis, and the way the author incorporated the different facets of DIDLS (three of which you explained well) strengthened my opinions. “Hocus-pocus” was an unusual word to use, but definitely correct in the context of this article. “Method” sounds very professional, which is not the author’s opinion towards the dieticians.
    Since syntax is personally the most difficult of DIDLS, your proficient explanation of the author’s use of syntax in the article was very helpful for me. However, I am not sure how syntax created a sarcastic tone when the author said “Schools can't afford foreign language courses, sports programs or music classes. But they found funds for dieticians?” Could you please explain.
    Overall, this was a thorough analysis of the entertaining, strong-voiced article.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Kathy--Your September Close Reading post was a better analysis than this one, I'm afraid. This is disorganized and contains inaccuracies and too little evidence.

    ReplyDelete