Sunday, October 20, 2013

Open Prompt (Part 1) October 20

AP English Literature and Composition 2009 Question 3

A Symbol

Essay #1: (I never thought handwriting would affect how a reader reads an essay, but I just learned what it's like to be a teacher, and boy is it hard work! Messy handwriting itself cannot and should not have an effect on the graders, but in this case (at least to me), I had a few issues with reading specific words. Overall, the quality of the essay was stellar, but it was frustrating at times not being able to read an entire sentence without deciphering what a word might have been. Now on to the actual analysis.) The student starts off with a strong entrance, answering the question within the first paragraph. He uses The Wild Duck by Henrik Ibsen to successfully explain how the symbol, the duck, is a reflection of the changes of characters throughout the essay. The students has specific examples in all paragraphs, however, some of the examples were a little vague, and without having read the book, I was slightly confused. The overall argument was successful however. The conclusion was a little lacking when it came to wrapping all the ideas back together, but it doesn't disturb the message of the essay too much. This essay may have received a 7 or 8.

Essay #2: I sighed in relief as I scrolled down and realized that this essay was written with big, neat handwriting. However, after reading the first sentence, I noted minor grammatical errors that disturbed the flow of sentences. I often found myself re-reading sections such as: "Tennessee Willimas play "A Streetcar Named Desire" uses a lamp shade to symbolize covering up the truth, and this example exposes Blanche  DuBois obsession with youth and her need to make everything in life appear better than it is." The student starts out well, giving a solid example of a symbol, but as the paragraphs go on, the students doesn't connect the reasons with the prompt and looses her argument in the middle. Even as the reader, I was constantly forgetting the main argument in her essay. Her examples did seem a bit lacking. She could have described them a bit more, but it was sufficient enough to get a main point across. Again, she does not reiterate her point about the lamps being the symbol for masking flaws. However, she does come back in the conclusion to tie the main idea together again. This essay may have received a 5-6.

Essay 3: This student starts off forgetting to underline her title of her novel and did not mention an author either. She also uses 'in my opinion' which is never something to put in an introduction. She was supposed to talk about the many aspects that the 'machette' symbolizes and how it affects the characters, but even in her introduction she only says "It symbolizes a higher level in power and the man who carried it was an intimidating man." That was her thesis. She then goes on to mentioning how the 'machette' was being used but none of the examples are solid ideas. Occasionally she goes off and gives extra details that do not pertain to the prompt. Her examples seem to be more of a 'matter of fact' kind of talk instead of showing the readers what she believes and why they support her argument. At the end, the students seems to have 2 conclusions. The first conclusion consists of multiple rhetorical questions aimed at the reader to dare the reader to refute her argument.  And by that point, the student doesn't even mention the word 'symbol' and does no connect the 1st convolution to the prompt. It seems at the end, she is trying to prove why the 'machette' gave Okonkwo power instead of why the 'machette' symbolized power. The second conclusion reiterates what was said in the 1st conclusion but makes far less sense. She goes to including 'w/' in her essay surprisingly. And even at the end, the student can be seen contradicting her self. The last sentence to her conclusion should have been at least tying all the part(s) together, however she did not and ends with "So it symbolizes pride. Most of all." This essay may have received a 2, or 3.

4 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Nice critiques, Kathy! I think it might have been a good idea to go into more detail when grading the first essay, however. I noticed that the symbolism of the duck was the only example you gave of the student's analytical ability. For the second essay, I found your criticisms to be spot on. The student definitely had some difficulty staying on topic and establishing effective warrants. Do you think the structure of the essay had something to do with its weaknesses? I thought the organization only made it more difficult to tie all the evidence back to the lampshade symbol. The third essay seemed to be written by a student in the process of learning English, but I do feel that their thesis made a thoughtful claim about symbolism in the piece. That being said, their issues stemmed from an inability to present and support that claim, and I think the student definitely deserved a low score.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Excellent job, Kathy. It's clear you read each response thoughtfully.
    In terms of the first essay, I find it interesting how much you differ from the AP Grader. The Grader cited the student's thesis as "rather vague, [and] weak," and his/her supporting evidence as "precise and controlled." You seem to claiming the inverse, saying that the entrance was "strong" and the examples were "a little vague." Why did you arrive at such different conclusions than the
    Grader? Maybe you should read their analyses to different perspective.
    For the second essay, I agree with you for the most part. Your analysis also happens to be much more in-depth than that of the AP Grader, who gives no reason for the student receiving a 6.
    In terms of the third essay, I think you lay into the student's misspelling of "machete" a little too harshly. He/she fixes the mistake part-way through. I also disagree with your assertion that the student had two different conclusions. I think he/she had one poorly articulated conclusion, that happened to be almost completely unsupported. Your low scoring was still definitely warranted.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Kathy, this was a well-written critique for the open-prompts.
    Deciphering the words against the impediment of awful handwriting is usually the most difficult task. So is fully understanding why the student got his/her score, which you explained proficiently.
    When I read the first student’s essay, I thought that he/she would earn a nine. However, now that you mention it, the conclusion does not seem complete. How would you have wrapped up the essay?
    Also, for the second student, do you think that the reason why he/she was deviating from the thesis is that he/she was running out of supporting arguments? That happens to me quite often when I do SAT or ACT essays. I hope that I do not make the that mistake on the AP exam, on which the standards are much higher.
    Overall, I thought that this was a thorough critique on the three essays.

    ReplyDelete